Topper softball season ends with trio of losses to Spring Valley
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.

CLOSE CALL — Glenwood City’s Libby Wagner was called out at home plate after being tagged by the Spring Valley pitcher during a regional softball game in Spring Valley May 20. —photo by Shawn DeWitt
The third time did not prove to be a charm for Glenwood City softball team who saw its 2022 season come to an end when it dropped a heartbreaking 8-7 decision to Spring Valley in the opening round of the WIAA Division 4 regional playoffs last Friday, May 20.
It was the third loss the Hilltoppers had suffered in Spring Valley in a five-day span.
Closing out the conference season, the Cardinals hosted the Hilltoppers Monday, May 16 for a pair of five-inning contests. After losing by a 2-1 score in the opener of the doubleheader, Glenwood City fell hard in the nightcap, lsoing 17-1.
With those three losses to Spring Valley and a 9-6 non-conference setback to Turtle Lake/Clayton Tuesday, May 17 at home in what was the regular-season finale, Glenwood City finished the year 0-15.
Spring Valley-Regional
Glenwood City had to wait an extra day to head back to Spring Valley for a Division 4 regional quarterfinal battle due to last Thursday’s thunderstorms.
The extra 24 hours of rest didn’t seem to help the Hilltoppers who fell behind 5-0 after one inning of play and trailed 6-0 after the second frame of the May 20 playoff contest.
But Glenwood City slowly pecked away at its deficit.
Looking to pick up its first win of the season and advance in the regional tournament, the Hilltoppers finally got on track in the top of the third inning. With two outs, Jenna McCarthy drew a walk, Alex Peterson and Madison Caress belted back-to-back singles that brought McCarthy to the plate with the Toppers’ first run of the game. Avery Rubenzer then reached on an error to load the bases. Izzy Davis then singled to score Peterson and Caress and make it a 6-3 game.

GLENWOOD CITY junior Aubree Logghe hit this pitch for a double in the fifth inning of the Hilltoppers regional softball game in Spring Valley last Friday, May 20. Logghe drove in a pair of runs with the hit to give Glenwood City a 7-6 lead. Unfortunately, the Cardinals rallied for an 8-7 win. —photo by Shawn DeWitt
In the fourth, Sydney Grant singled and scored to cut the Toppers’ deficit to two runs.
Glenwood City would take its first lead of the game in the fifth inning. Caress and Davis netted their second hits in the game to reach base. Both came in to score on a double off the bat of junior Aubree Logghe who in turn scored on sophomore Libby Wagner’s base hit to give the Hilltoppers a 7-6 advantage.
Unfortunately, Spring Valley regained the advantage with a pair of runs in the bottom half of the fifth and held on for the 8-7 victory.
In that final contest of the year, Glenwood City had its best offensive performance collecting a dozen hits as McCarthy, Peterson, Caress and Davis all finished with a pair.
Maddie Klatt had a solid effort in the throwing circle despite the loss. She gave up eight runs on eight hits, struck out two and surrendered just one free base.
Turtle Lake/Clayton
Glenwood City was locked in a three all tie with Turtle Lake/Clayton at home last Tuesday, May 17.
But the Lakers put up five runs in the fourth inning and added another in the fifth to take a 9-3 lead.
The Hilltoppers tried to rally scoring a run in the bottom of the fifth and then a pair in their final at-bat in the seventh but came up short in the regular-season finale, losing 9 to 6.
Madison Caress had a hot bat for the Hilltopper as she collected three of the team’s six hits and scored a run. McCarthy, Peterson and Logghe combined for the team’s other three hits.
Maddie Klatt started in the throwing circle and went four innings giving up eight runs on eight hits to take the loss. She finished with seven Ks. Jenna McCarthy came on in the fifth frame and threw the final three innings allowing another run on two hits with five strikeouts.
Spring Valley-Game 1
The opening game of last Monday’s doubleheader in Spring Valley was a close one.
The Cardinals scored a run in the first and held on to that advantage until the top of the fifth and final inning when Sydney Grant led off the frame with a single and scored on Aubree Logghe’s sacrifice to knot the game at one all.
But Spring Valley scored the game winner in the bottom half of the fifth for the 2-1 victory.
Despite a solid pitching effort, Maddie Klatt took the loss. In four and a third innings, Klatt only gave up two runs on eight hits and walked a pair while striking out two.
Glenwood City also had eight hits in the game, all singles by different players.
Spring Valley-Game 2
Glenwood City trailed 4 to 1 just two inning into game number two.
But a five-run third gave the Hilltoppers a 6-4 advantage.
Spring Valley, however, answered with three runs of their own in the third and then tacked on four more scores in the fourth and six runs in the fifth and final inning for a 17-6 advantage.
Glenwood City was only able to put one more run on the scoreboard in its final atbat and lost 17-7.
Glenwood City finished with nine hits as Alex Peterson, Avery Rubenzer and Sydney Grant each picked up two hits. Madison Caress, Michaela Blaser and Izzy Davis each had a hit.
Maddie Klatt and Jenna McCarthy split time in the pitching circle with Klatt going the first three frames allowing seven runs on four hits to take the loss. McCarthy threw the final two innings giving up the final five runs on five hits.

