LTE – Janet Scepurek – 12-21-2016
To The Editor:
On Tuesday, December 6, there were quite a few public comments made by citizens at the St. Croix County Board meeting. The entire meeting’s broadcast is available on the county website. It was a great example of our government in action with many citizens participating. Most of the people who attended were in regard to the proposed moratorium to give the county more time to study the issues regarding the proposed CAFO at Emerald Sky Dairy.
My comment was a book report on a book titled The Wind Farm Scam, by Dr. John Etherington, who is a retired ecology professor from the University of Wales. He states that wind turbines cannot generate enough energy to reduce global CO2 levels to a meaningful degree. The intermittent nature of wind power cannot generate a steady output, necessitating back-up from coal- and gas-powered plants, which significantly negates any saving of greenhouse gas emissions. There are ecological drawbacks including damage to wildlife and habitats. Wind power is being excessively financed at the cost of consumers and taxpayers.
A scam is often defined as “an attempt to swindle people which involves gaining their confidence.” The repeated reference to tackling climate change as a motivation for wind power and the constant citation of the 1997 Kyoto treaty targets is just such an attempt to gain public confidence. The specter of climate change is being used as a scare tactic to get people to buy wind power.
Some of the loudest voices in the development of the wind industry come from the same large companies which are responsible for excessive release of CO2 (the supposed reason for needing renewables in the first place). Wind turbines are ineffective because they frequently cannot run at all, and for much of the time generate less than maximum output. They pose many problems for the integration of wind with other power and reduce the marketability of the output. The average load factor of wind farms averages only 26%. The paradox of building windmills is that you have to build a lot of ordinary power stations to back them up, and those are going to be almost certainly gas in the short to medium term.
In the US there is a system of covert tax breaks and offsets: (1) federal production tax credit, (2) accelerated depreciation, (3) avoidance of state corporate taxes, (4) state production tax credits or subsidies for wind farm owners, (5) state renewable portfolio standard, and (6) other tax breaks and subsidies. So lucrative is the US arrangement that UK-based BP and Netherlands-based Shell are investing heavily in wind power in the US. This permits the two companies to avoid tens or hundreds of millions in federal and state income tax on their profits, including oil profits!
The unpredictability of wind power dictates that the power could not be sold in the marketplace unless legislation forces the issue. At the end of the book the author talks about An Inconvenient Truth. The 1990 IPCC’s first report showed a graph of the temperature changes from 1000 to 1990. Dr. David Deming received an email “we have to get rid of the medieval warm period” so a reconstruction was published. The 3rd IPCC report in 2001 showed the hockey stick shape of the graph and similar graph of CO2 which had become the trademark of global warming, featured in hundreds of presentations and press reports as “proof” that CO2 was warming the earth; the hockey stick had been created by statistical manipulation.
Dr. Etherington states that CO2 may or may not play a role in controlling global temperatures; other factors are more likely a cause of sudden warming and cooling events.
Janet Scepurek
Forest Township

