City opens discussion on mining agreement with Vista Sand
GLENWOOD CITY — Mayor John Larson concluded the open council meeting Monday night saying, “It was February second or third of last year that Scott Teigen first approached me about the city annexing the proposed sand mine site.” He continued, “a lot of time has already been invested in it and we need to keep on this every week until we can come to an agreement or we can not.”
Larson was referring to the discussion about the proposed mining agreement with Vista Sand on mining frac sand on a site in the Town of Glenwood just south of the city limits. Vista Sand last month presented the city with a proposed mining agreement and Larson presented copies to each member of the city council for study and Monday evening, February 3rd the council held a meeting at the Community Center with Vista Sand and allowed the public to question the proposal. If the city and Vista Sand can come to some agreement, then the question is will the council approved annexing the almost 500 acres of land owned by the Teigen and Crosby families into the city.
Vista Sand CEO R. J. Sikes, their attorney Anders Helquist and Geologist Ken Severson from UW-Eau Claire fielded questions from about 18 local citizens that gathered for the meeting.
More had concerns about private water wells, truck traffic, and noise. Jack Bennett questioned the council on who was going to police the items addressed in the proposed mining agreement. The proposal calls for the city to received seven cents per ton of sand removed and Bennett suggested, “why not ask for more?” He suggested that the council negotiate for more saying fifteen cents.
Greg Holden, President of the Village of Downing addressed the council with his concerns including noise levels, hours of operation and the private wells in the village. The proposal that the council had received has Vista Sand requesting operation 24/7 and Holden suggested Monday to Friday 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. Their proposal also offered private well guarantee to ten private well owners near Downing. Holden noted that there are 60-65 homes in Downing and asked that they all be included in the guarantee.
Severson addressed the well question by noting the depth of the mine site well and that the ground water flow at the site is away from the Village. When he was told that wells in Downing are about 40 feet deep, Severson said, “I would be concerned about that, especially if you fertilizer your lawn.”
It was noted that the proposed agreement deviated from the recently completed city mining ordinance and Ken Peterson stated, “a lot of time was spent working on the ordinance – it’s good and fair information in there and it needs to be added as an exhibit to the proposal.”
Also questioned was what would happened if Vista Sand goes bankrupt and then who would be responsible to clean up the area and reclaim the ground?
Sikes addressed some of the concerns of the public noting that, “there had been a lot of good comments and great points.” He talked about the forming of a citizen task force to address local concerns and noted that in other areas it has worked pretty well.
Helquist answered the bankrupt question by saying, “Before you put a shovel into the ground you need financial assurance in place like cash, a bond or a letter of credit.”
Sikes addressed the need for the 24-hour, seven day a week operation noting that machinery takes two to three hours of start up time and another hour to shut down.
Tom Quinn, a Downing resident was concerned about the noise, “the most trouble would be the low level noise.” He noted that with the processing equipment running it could have that level of sound, and “It’s hardest to deal with and may reduce property values.”
After about an hour and a half of discussion the council went into closed session so they could discuss the proposed agreement. Following the closed session the council came back with several counter proposals.
Mayor Larson addressed those Tuesday forenoon and indicated that they did not try to address every item this time. But he did indicated that the council would stay with what the new ordinance states including keeping the noise at 60 dBA and keeping the well and property value guarantees to a half mile from the mine site compared to what Vista Sand was requesting of about 500 feet.
The council also is asking for a twenty-cents per ton fee over the seven cents offered by Vista Sand, but the council would agreed to allow 40 acres of mining, which would be a change from the 35 that is in the ordinance. They would also allow for 24/7 for mining and processing, but would limit the truck movements to six days a week and restrict truck traffic one hour in the morning and one hour in the afternoon to allow for school bus traffic.
The council will again address this issue at their regular meeting next Monday night, February 10th. They will be meeting at 7:00 p.m. at the Municipal Building.

