Emerald Sky Dairy fined $80,000 for December 2016 manure spill
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
HUDSON — A St. Croix County judge has ordered Emerald Sky Dairy to pay $80,000 in forfeitures, surcharges and costs associated with a manure spill in a nearby wetland in December of 2016.
St. Croix County Circuit Court Judge Scott R. Needham signed the order for judgment May 21.
The judgment includes forfeitures of $54,335.03; a 26 percent penalty surcharge of $14,127.11; a 20 percent environmental surcharge of $10,867.01; $25 in court costs; a $13 crime laboratories and drug law enforcement surcharge; a $68 court support services surcharge; a 1 percent jail surcharge of $543.35; and a $21.50 justice information surcharge.
Payments of $16,000 are due on or before September 1 in 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023.
Following an investigation by the state Department of Natural Resources, DNR personnel turned the case over to the state Department of Justice.
State Attorney General Joshua L. Kaul and Assistant Attorney General Emily M. Ertel filed the civil complaint in St. Croix County May 3.
Emerald Sky Dairy, located on County Road G in the Town of Emerald, is owned by Todd Tuls, with an office address in Rising City, Nebraska.
State law requires a large concentrated animal feeding operation (CAFO) to have a Wisconsin Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (WPDES) permit.
A WPDES permit was issued to Emerald Dairy on July 1, 2015, and the permit was transferred to Emerald Sky Dairy effective March 1, 2016, when Tuls purchased the business.
A wetland delineation was performed at Emerald Sky Dairy in 2016 in anticipation of a proposed expansion to increase the number of animal units to 8,804. A dairy cow represents 1.4 animal units, so the proposed expansion would have translated into 6,289 cows.
In 2016, the facility’s current conditional use permit allowed up to 3,400 dairy cows, or 4,760 animal units, and the existing operation had 2,460 animal units, or 1,757 dairy cows.
Transfer pipe
A manure transfer pipe carried approximately 20,000 to 30,000 gallons of manure daily from the Transition Management Facility (TMF) barn to the separator building, and in December of 2016, a crack developed in a clean-out riser on the manure transfer pipe close to and south of the separator building.
Manure leaked from the transfer pipe into two wetlands on site, including an open pond, flowed through a ditch around the TMF barn to the stormwater pond, which then overflowed manure and manure-laden water into another wetland.
The broken pipe was discovered on December 19, 2016, and on that date, Emerald Sky Dairy hired Komro Sales and Service Inc. to repair the broken manure transfer pipe.
Three months later, on March 28, 2017, St. Croix County received anonymous tips that a manure spill had occurred at Emerald Sky Dairy.
The next day, Steve Olson, a St. Croix County Land Conservation Use specialist, visited Emerald Sky Dairy, confirmed the manure spill, and told Elizabeth Griffith, Emerald Sky Dairy’s director of safety, to report the spill to the state Department of Natural Resources.
Griffith reported the manure spill to the DNR on the same day that Olson confirmed the manure spill.
Three feet deep
DNR staff took water samples and depth measurements of manure solids on March 31, 2017.
Manure solids in the open pond ranged from 13 inches deep to more than three feet deep, according to the civil complaint.
“At one location on the southern end of the open pond, the yard stick was fully submerged in manure solids and did not reach the bottom of the solids,” the complaint states.
Immediately south of the open pond, manure solids were about 15 inches deep, and manure solids in the ditch west of the TMF barn were 12 to 13 inches deep.
The water sample from the stormwater pond had E. coli bacteria of 7,980 CFU/100 milliliters. (CFU means “colony-forming units.”)
The civil complaint notes, “For purpose of comparison, DNR’s Beach Monitoring Program requires closure of public beaches on lakes when water quality samples are above 1,000 CFU/100mL for E. coli. The Beach Monitoring program requires an advisory notice warning the public to swim at their own risk when water quality samples are above 235 CFU/100mL for E. coli.”
In other words, the E. coli level in the Emerald Sky Dairy stormwater pond was nearly 34 times the level that requires an advisory notice warning the public to swim at their own risk at a beach.
The civil complaint also sates that the stormwater pond had a Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) level of 547 milligrams/liter, and the wetland sample had a BOD level of 497 mg/L. Untreated municipal waste typically has a BOD level between 100 and 300 mg/L.
The stormwater pond and the wetlands also had elevated ammonia levels, according to the complaint.
Clean-up
Emerald Sky Dairy began cleaning up the manure discharge on April 1, 2017.
Water was drained out of the stormwater pond three times over the course of the clean-up to remove manure liquids in the pond and in the ditch and wetlands upstream that washed down to the stormwater pond.
A wide-tracked excavator also was used to scrape 3,455.54 tons of manure from the wetlands.
According to a report dated July 31, 2017, by Williams Engineering Services, LLC, representatives of Emerald Sky Dairy admitted the manure transfer pipe had failed sometime between December 9 and December 19 of 2016 and estimated that no more than 275,000 gallons of liquid manure were discharged.
Violations
The civil complaint charges Emerald Sky Dairy with four separate violations.
Violation No. 1 relates to the unauthorized discharge of pollutants to waters of the state under Wisconsin Administrative Code NR 151.08(4) and the dairy’s WPDES permit when manure was discharged into the wetlands “from around December 9, 2016, until at least December 19, 2016.”
Violation No. 2 relates to Emerald Sky Dairy’s failure to report the manure spill.
Under the WPDES permit, Emerald Sky Dairy is required to verbally report the manure spill within 24 hours and report it in writing within five days.
Emerald Sky Dairy discovered the manure spill on December 19, 2016, but did not report it to the DNR until March 29, 2017, and then reported it only after a St. Croix County land use specialist instructed the dairy to report the manure spill following anonymous tips to St. Croix County and the DNR, the civil complaint notes.
Violation No. 3 relates to Emerald Sky Dairy’s failure to mitigate the adverse impacts to the wetlands resulting from the manure spill.
From December 19, 2016, until March 31, 2017, the manure spill was polluting the wetlands, but “Emerald Sky Dairy took no reasonable steps to minimize or prevent adverse impacts to the wetlands,” according to the complaint.
Violation No. 4 relates to Emerald Sky Dairy’s failure to operate, maintain and inspect the facilities to prevent discharges to the wetlands.
The dairy’s WPDES permit requires weekly inspections of liquid manure storage and containment structures, but Emerald Sky Dairy did not conduct weekly inspections from March 1, 2016, until March 15, 2017, according to the complaint.
“If Emerald Sky Dairy had been inspecting its liquid storage and containment structures as required by the WPDES permit, Emerald Sky Dairy would have noticed hundreds of thousands of gallons of manure were missing. Upon making this discovery, a reasonable operator would have investigated and likely discovered the leaking manure transfer pipe earlier, mitigating the magnitude of the manure discharge,” the complaint states.
Penalties
According to state law, the circuit court in the county where the violation occurred has jurisdiction to enforce the state law pertaining to discharging pollutants to waters of the state.
Wisconsin Statute 283.91(2) states that the fine for polluting waters of the state ranges from $10 per day to $10,000 per day, except that the minimum does not apply if the point source for the violation is an animal feeding operation.
If the maximum penalty had been assessed for the time from December 19, 2016, when the transfer pipe was repaired and April 1, 2017, when Emerald Sky Dairy began cleaning up the manure spill, the fine would have been a little more than $1 million.
The civil complaint requests restoration of the wetlands, forfeitures under Wisconsin Statute 283.91(2), the cost of the investigation and prosecution, the penalty surcharge, environmental surcharge, court costs, crime lab surcharge, court support services surcharge, the jail surcharge and justice information surcharge.
All together, Emerald Sky Dairy spent $152,519 on cleanup of the manure spill.
According to a report from Ecosystems LLC out of Rice Lake, based on a preliminary study to evaluate the wetland cleanup in August of 2017 and a follow-up site visit in November of 2018, the wetlands were adequately restored.
Ecosystems recommended re-establishing pre-discharge site elevations in a central part of the wetland by regrading or filling a central ditch channel that had been uncovered during the initial manure removal and clean-up.
The central ditch channel would have been created 10 to 20 years before the manure spill during site preparation for Emerald Dairy and was unrelated to the manure spill, the Ecosystems report states.

