Skip to content

No Calls: Boyceville loses heartbreaker and D-SC wrestling championship to Spring Valley/Elmwood

SPRING VALLEY — Were they pins or weren’t they?

It is a question that will long be debated, especially by the Boyceville coaches, wrestlers and their fans.

In a dual between state-ranked Division 3 wrestling powers Boyceville and Spring Valley/Elmwood that was chalked full of decisive matches and moves and monumental decisions, it was what did not – or better yet, was not called – that may have been a deciding factor in the outcome of last Thursday’s much anticipated dual at Spring Valley High School.

Twice the Bulldogs were denied calls, by the dual’s official, on what appeared to be pins – once at 120 pounds and again in the final match at 145 pounds. The former brought the Boyceville coaches to the scoring table for a lively discussion with the official Gail Pronschinske and the Bulldogs fans to their feet and their voices to full-throttle.

A pin call in either match would have meant victory for the Bulldogs.

Instead, it was heartbreak once again for 11th ranked Boyceville as archrival and nemesis Spring Valley/Elmwood, polling at number eight in the latest on line poll, denied Boyceville the Dunn-St. Croix wrestling crown for the fourth straight year while claiming its eighth straight conference championship with a thrilling and yet gut-wrenching 36-35 victory January  26.     

“It was a great dual meet as always,” said a diplomatic and subdued  Jamie Olson, Boyceville’s head coach, following the match. “Our kids wrestled their hearts out. We talked about wrestling for six minutes and not leaving anything behind and we did that.”

While the no calls loomed large in the final tally they were by no means the only points that Boyceville was unable to secure.

“We didn’t capitalize on bonus point opportunities and I give their (Spring Valley/Elmwood) kids credit for wrestling defensive and not giving up pins,” added Olson. “That was the difference.”

“We wrestled well enough to win, we need to make a few adjustments with some guys and we will be fine,” Olson stated.

160 and 182 pounds were golden opportunities for the Bulldogs to “max out” its team points with pins. But the Cardinals wrestlers facing both Brock Schlough and James Palmer were able to do just what Olson noted – stay off their back.

Instead of six points in each of those matches, Schlough and Palmer finished with technical falls and five points. A pin in just one of those would have knotted the dual and a pair of falls would have tipped the scale in the Bulldogs’ favor.

The Cardinals also took advantage of their opportunities scoring six points in five of its seven match wins including three pins and three forfeits and had close wins in two other matches.

Boyceville finished with just two pins and a forfeit.

And while all those factored into the final outcome, most that witnessed the epic battle will likely only remember the pins that weren’t.

With Boyceville leading by ten points, 28-18, Nick Goodell, honorable mention a 126 pounds, had his Cardinal opponent Clayton Neisinger on his back for several seconds as third-period time in the 120-pound match expired. 

Goodell even pushed on Neisinger’s shoulders for maximum effect and it appeared that the Cardinal wrestler was pinned, several times over. But no pin from the official was forthcoming. Instead, Goodell had to settle for a 14-0 blanking and the Bulldogs’ four team points.

The no call drew the ire of the Boyceville coaches and fans alike. 

The Cardinals notched six-point wins in the next three matches – two forfeits (126 and 138) and a pin (132) – to take a 36-32 lead its first since it lead 6-5 early in the dual.

The Bulldogs needed a major decision victory to tie or a technical fall or pin to win in the final match at 145 pounds. 

That heavy burden fell onto the shoulders of Jerod Nelson who was equal to the task.

Deadlocked at five late in the final period against the Cardinals’ Santana Schlegel, Nelson threw on a head lock and took Schlegel straight to his back. But again, despite appearances to the contrary, no pin call was made.

As the final ticks of the dual ran off the clock, Nelson earned a 10-5 victory but the three team points left Boyceville a point shy in the final tally.

Host Spring Valley/Elmwood drew first blood in the dual that began at 152 pounds as Cooper Stevens nipped the Bulldogs’ Sam Retz 9-7.

Schlough, ranked number one, gave Boyceville its first lead in the subsequent match at 160 with a 19-4 technical fall over Kenny Fesenmaier.

At 170, Spring Valley won another close decision as second-ranked Cruze Hurlburt jumped from 138 pounds to beat Justin Malean 3-0.

Boyceville would win four of the next five matches beginning with the Bulldogs’ top-rated James Palmer’s 17-0 technical fall whitewashing of state-ranked Carter Merth at 182.

At 195, yet another of the Bulldogs number one wrestlers Garret Joles score a first-period pin.

Noah Novotney accepted a forfeit at heavyweight and Eli Swanson scored a big pin at 106 pounds to up the Bulldogs lead to 28-12.

But Spring Valley would rally for the win. 

“They found a way to win tonight, we need to find a way to win down the road,” concluded Olson.

Boyceville finished out the regular and conference season when it hosted Mondovi last night. The Bulldogs will then go to the Big Rivers/Dunn St. Croix Conference Challenge in River Falls this Saturday while a loaded regional tournament looms on the horizon.

Spring Valley/Elmwood 36, Boyceville 35

152-Cooper Stevens (SVE) dec. Sam Retz (B), 9-7; 160-Brock Schlough (B) tech falled Kenny Fesenmaier (SVE), 19-4 ; 170-Cruze Hurlburt (SVE) dec. Justin Malean (B), 3-0; 182-James Palmer (B) tech falled Carter Merth (SVE), 17-0; 195-Garrett Joles (B) pinned Nick Hofacker (SVE), 1:04; 220-Austin Turner (SVE) pinned Hunter Lipke (B), 2:29; 285-Noah Novotney (B) received forfeit; 106– Eli Swanson (B) pinned Ben Anderson (SVE), 1:45; 113-Luke Deppa (SVE) pinned Shiann Wagner (B), 1:10; 120-Nick Goodell (B) majored Clayton Neisinger (SVE), 14-0; 126-Riley Merth (SVE) received forfeit; 132-Dylan Bune (SVE) pinned Micadin Kahl (B), 2:39; 138-Seth Schlegel (SVE) received forfeit; 145-Jerod Nelson (B) dec. Santana Schlegel (SVE), 10-5.