Dunn County announces implementation of proxy tool
DUNN COUNTY — Menomonie Police Chief Atkinson, Dunn County Sheriff Smith, and UW Stout Police Chief Walter are pleased to announce the implementation and use of a new tool known as a “proxy” to address offenders in the field. Use of the proxy by the City of Menomonie began in June, 2016 with all three departments utilizing this tool effective October, 2016.
A proxy is an evidence-based risk assessment tool used by law enforcement during their initial contact with an offender to help aid law enforcement in the decision whether to arrest and what charges to refer to the Office of the District Attorney. Evidence-based decision making is the practice of using research-based findings to guide decisions across the justice system. According to Sheriff Smith, “Evidence-based decision making is a tool that marks a significant change in the way law enforcement documents how we deal with offenders. Changing times and crimes require changing strategies on how to best handle offenders.” Law enforcement poses a series of questions to the offender and, based on those responses in conjunction with the offense, determines whether the offender is a low, medium, or high risk to re-offend. Questions by law enforcement include the offender’s current age, age of first arrest, and number of prior adult arrests.
Through the use of the proxy, certain first time or low risk offenders may now be eligible for diversion from the traditional justice system and referred directly by law enforcement to the Dunn County District Attorney’s Office Pre-Charge Diversion Program (the “Program”). The Program is available for certain low risk or first time offenders where research indicates an offender will “self-correct” and more harm than good will come to the community and the offender if the offender is placed in the traditional criminal justice system. The Program is limited to certain low-level, non-violent crimes such as disorderly conduct, obstructing an officer, or theft of less than $100. District Attorney Andrea Nodolf spearheaded the Program through collaboration with the Dunn County Criminal Justice Coordinating Council (“CJCC”) where she served as the Chair of the CJCC’s Deferred Prosecution Work Group. According to UW Stout Chief Lisa Walter, “As chair of the Deferred Prosecution Work Group, District Attorney Nodolf was able to push for change and collaborate with all agencies within the system to create the best possible program.”
Research has shown that certain offenders assessed as low risk to re-offend do not benefit from traditional behavior changing programming, and are in fact more likely to re-offend when overly programmed or supervised. The Program is a win-win for both the community as a whole and the offender. According to Chief Atkinson “Implementing change through law enforcement can be difficult, but the Menomonie Police Department believes utilizing evidence-based decisions can help not only the offender, but the community as a whole.” The Program is beneficial to taxpayers as they benefit from reduced court costs and increased public safety both by having an offender that does not re-offend and allowing prosecutors to focus their limited time on violent and high risk offenders. The courts, prosecutors, and law enforcement agencies benefit as they save court time and resources associated with trials and court hearings, thereby preserving limited resources. Offenders benefit from the Program as it diverts the offender from the criminal justice system, avoids criminal charges being recorded in public databases, and provides offenders with an educational component.
Offenders referred to the Program must undergo both a substantial background check and receive permission from any victims to the crime before being accepted into the Program. Once enrolled, the offender is placed on a six (6) month Pre-Charge Diversion Program Agreement (the “Agreement”) that is supervised by the Deferred Prosecution Coordinator for the District Attorney’s Office. During the six (6) month period, the offender must meet the Program requirements including not committing new crimes, completing community service at a non-profit agency, undergoing programming, paying any victim restitution, obtaining an alcohol and other drug assessment if appropriate, and completing any other requirements deemed necessary by the District Attorney’s Office. If successful, the offender avoids a criminal record. Failure to successfully complete the Program may result in revocation of the Agreement and filing of charges.
District Attorney Andrea Nodolf has been very impressed with how these agencies have utilized the proxy risk assessment tool and support the Pre-Charge Diversion Program. Commenting on the Program, District Attorney Nodolf states, “The Pre-Charge Diversion Program allows my office to be smart on crime and divert those certain low risk, first time offenders which research shows will self- correct, and focus our limited time and resources on the medium to high risk offenders who pose a greater threat to the safety of this community.”
