DC judge sentences former Colfax man to 7 years in prison, 10 years of extended supervision
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — A Dunn County judge has revoked a plea agreement and has sentenced a 23-year-old former Colfax man who pleaded guilty to the repeated sexual assault of a teenager to seven years in prison and 10 years of extended supervision.
Dylan M. Reidel appeared with his attorney, Travis Gaetz, before Judge Rod Smeltzer for a revocation hearing July 2.
Reidel was sentenced in July of 2019 for the repeated sexual assault of a child, which is a Class C felony that carries a penalty of up to 40 years in prison, said Amber Hahn, Dunn County assistant district attorney.
Sentence was withheld, and Reidel was placed on five years of probation, and as a condition of probation, was ordered to spend one year in jail, with Huber privileges if sex offender treatment was started within three months, she said.
In addition, Reidel was allowed Huber privileges to work so he could pay child support and was ordered to have no contact with juvenile girls without the approval of the Department of Corrections, Hahn said.
Reidel was released from jail in November of 2020 and then absconded from probation. He had received approval to live in Eau Claire and had been assigned a probation agent in Eau Claire, she said.
The defendant absconded from checking in with his probation agent for four months. Police officers had contact with Reidel on February 17, 2021, and he had weapons in his possession — knives and swords — as well as methamphetamine and drug paraphernalia, Hahn said.
He had also started having contact with a 14-year-old girl starting one month prior to February 17, and he was found in the company of the 14-year-old in a vehicle in a secluded area. The girl was partially clothed, she said.
The judge will not be addressing the charges that are pending for the most recent incident during the revocation hearing, but the pending charges are relevant for the revocation hearing for the protection of the public and to establish a pattern of conduct, Hahn said.
Juvenile court
Reidel also has a history in the juvenile court system, where he was convicted of sexually assaulting younger family members, Hahn said.
The defendant received treatment in the juvenile system at Alpha House and at Positive Alternatives, she said.
The case to which the revocation hearing applies involved two victims who were 14 years old when Reidel was 20 and involved multiple instances of sexual intercourse. Reidel is 23 years old now, and the alleged victim from February of this year was 14 years old, Hahn said.
After a year in jail and being placed on probation, the defendant has failed to get sex offender treatment. He has no job, and he has failed to check in with his probation agent. At this point, the only tool left to protect the public is incarceration, Hahn said.
No intervention has been successful to protect juvenile girls. Sexual assault alters the life of a juvenile, she said.
Reidel pleaded guilty to a Class C felony and knew he faced a possible 40 years in prison, Hahn said.
With 40 years hanging over his head, the defendant failed to take it seriously, she said.
A 40-year felony was not an incentive to show up or make a telephone call to his probation agent. The defendant has done nothing to make himself better, Hahn said.
Brain development
Reidel will be 24 years old in December, and research shows that the defendant’s brain development is not complete yet. Research also has shown that methamphetamine further inhibits brain development, Hahn said.
The defendant needs to be in custody until his brain development catches up, she said, and recommended that the judge sentence Reidel to 10 years of initial confinement and 15 years of extended supervision, with 782 days of credit for time served.
Sex offender treatment can be ordered in the prison system. Sex offender research also shows that the risk of repeating the offense does not go down until people are much older, and Reidel already has four juvenile victims, Hahn said.
The defendant needs probation intervention. He has shown he cannot do it on his own, and there is a need to protect the public and a need for treatment, she said, adding that by creating another victim of sexual assault, Reidel has exhibited “a disturbing pattern of conduct.”
Nothing the court has done or that Reidel has done has interrupted the pattern so far, she said.
Accountability
Instead of the 10 years of initial confinement that Hahn recommended, Gaetz, Reidel’s attorney, recommended seven years of initial confinement and 15 years of extended supervision.
Gaetz said Reidel did not expect to not be held accountable and that he expected to be sentenced to prison at the revocation hearing.
The defendant understands there is a need for treatment and for confinement, he said.
Reidel did meet with his probation agent in Dunn County before moving to Eau Claire, and he did meet with a counselor and also worked while he was on Huber, Gaetz said.
“What do we do from here?” Gaetz asked, noting that he had served as a probation agent himself for six years.
What is the appropriate sentence for Reidel to get the help he needs without being in prison so long that he becomes institutionalized? he asked.
Gaetz said he agreed with Hahn’s recommendation of extended supervision for 15 years because the follow-up is more important than the initial confinement.
Reidel wants to be a productive member of society, and he knows he needs to make changes, Gaetz said.
Brain development during incarceration is not ideal, but seven years is a realistic amount of time for initial confinement, he said.
Supervision
Judge Smeltzer said he had reviewed the packet of information provided to the court and that the recommendation from the probation agent was five or six years of extended supervision.
Why is there a recommendation for extended supervision for 15 years from Hahn and Gaetz that deviates from the other recommendation? Judge Smeltzer asked.
After speaking with Reidel, and based upon his experience as a probation agent and his experience in writing Pre-sentence Investigation reports and alternate PSIs for the defense, incarceration is necessary for treatment and to protect the public, Gaetz said.
The Department of Corrections is recommending 10 years of initial confinement and five years of extended supervision, he said, adding that he does not believe the recommendation is appropriate.
Seven years of initial confinement and 15 years of extended supervision will help with the follow through and will give Reidel time to get treatment, time to prove himself and time to build skills in the community, Gaetz said.
Defendant
Judge Smeltzer asked Reidel if he wished to address the court.
Reidel said he agreed with the recommendation of seven years of initial confinement and 15 years of extended supervision.
As Assistant District Attorney Hahn pointed out, Reidel had 40 years “hanging over his head,” the judge said.
“What were you thinking?” Judge Smeltzer asked.
Reidel responded that he did not know what he was thinking and that he was “young and dumb.”
The defendant was given an opportunity to avoid long-term incarceration but violated the conditions of his probation and has allegedly committed another serious offense with another juvenile victim, Judge Smeltzer said.
The judge then ordered Reidel to serve seven years of initial confinement with 10 years of extended supervision, stating that 10 years of extended supervision is a sufficient amount of time.
Reidel is 23 years old now and will be 40 years old when the extended supervision is finished, Judge Smeltzer noted.
The judge also allowed 782 days of credit for time served.

