Colfax rejects DCWS&R proposal for non-mandated recycling and admin services
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
COLFAX — The Colfax Village Board has rejected a new proposal from Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling to provide non-mandated recycling drop-off and administrative services.
Morgan Gerk, director of DCSW&R, held a Zoom meeting with representatives of the municipalities in Dunn County to provide additional options of keeping the transfer station west of Menomonie open as a collection site for non-mandated recycling materials and administrative services for Responsible Units, said Lynn Niggemann, village administrator-clerk-treasurer, at a special meeting of the Colfax Village Board September 2.
Enough municipalities have dropped out of Dunn County’s solid waste and recycling program that it is no longer feasible for the county to continue the program.
The Colfax Village Board has approved withdrawing from the county solid waste and recycling program and operating the Colfax collection site as the Responsible Unit.
The Towns of Colfax, Grant, Otter Creek and Tainter are intending to join the Colfax RU when it has been approved by the state Department of Natural Resources.
The DNR has a deadline of October 1 for all application materials for the RU.
The Colfax RU would begin operating the Colfax collection site as of January 1.
The Village of Colfax owns the collection site, and under the existing agreement, leases the site to Dunn County for $1 per year.
Under state law, all municipalities must either be an RU for recycling or must join another RU.
Under the existing DCSW&R program, the county is acting as the RU for the member municipalities.
Gerk asked representatives of the municipalities at the meeting on August 27 to have a special meeting of their village and town boards to determine if the boards wanted to participate in a non-mandated recycling program through Dunn County at the transfer station and whether the boards wanted Dunn County do the administrative work for each RU.
Non-mandated recyclables include tires, batteries, electronics, used oil, certain plastics, and some demolition materials (such as aluminum siding).
The Colfax collection site is intending to accept non-mandated recyclables after the Colfax RU begins operating the site.
Per capita
If all of the municipalities participated in the non-mandated recycling, the cost would be $10.28 per person per year, Niggemann said.
In addition to the non-mandated recycling per capita, people who bring the materials to the transfer station also would be charged a fee for service to drop off their non-mandated recyclables, she said.
If some municipalities drop out of the non-mandated recycling, then the per capita increases, Niggemann said.
The price keeps escalating as municipalities drop out, commented Mark Halpin, who chaired the meeting since Scott Gunnufson, village president, attended by telephone.
The total cost for Colfax at $10.28 per capita would be an additional $11,256 for non-mandated recyclables, Niggemann said.
The total cost for all of the municipalities in the Colfax RU would be nearly $60,000 for non-mandated recyclables.
As for the administrative services portion of the proposal, the services would include filing an annual report with the DNR for 2021 that would be due in 2022 and sending out education materials on recycling to all of the residents in the Colfax RU, Niggemann said.
The per capita fee for the administrative portion of the proposal, if all municipalities in Dunn County take advantage of it, would be $6.10 per person, Niggemann said.
Niggemann said she believed it would be more equitable to charge a flat fee for the administrative services rather than a per capita and said she had called Gerk to say the administrative should be on a fee for service basis.
For all of the municipalities in the Colfax RU, the administrative fee based on the per capita would be a minimum of about $35,000.
Since it is not very likely that all municipalities in Dunn County would agree to the administrative services, the cost for the Colfax RU would be closer to $50,000 or more, Niggemann said.
Chippewa County does the administrative services for the City of Chippewa Falls RU for a flat fee of $10,000, she said.
In the 2010 census, Chippewa Falls had a population of 13,661, more than double the population of the member municipalities in the Colfax RU.
The Chippewa Falls fee for administrative services works out to be about 73 cents per person.
Niggemann said when she spoke to Chippewa County officials, she learned that most of the municipalities in Chippewa County do not offer solid waste collection sites, only recycling, and that residents are on their own to contract with a commercial hauler for solid waste.
The Colfax Village Board unanimously approved a motion to not contract with Dunn County for nom-mandated recyclables and to not contract for administrative services.
Voting in favor of the motion were Gunnufson, Halpin and Village Trustees Carey Davis, Logan Michels, Annie Jenson and Margaret Burcham.
Village Trustee Gary Stene was absent from the special meeting.

