Skip to content

Colfax streets committee recommends 50-50 cost share on Maple Street tree

By LeAnn R. Ralph

COLFAX  — The Colfax Village Board’s streets committee is recommending a 50-50 split on the cost of taking down a lightning-damaged tree on Maple Street at the home of Jane Dobbs.

The authority exists to take down a tree creating an obstruction under the village’s ordinances in Section 6-2-5, said Lynn Niggemann, village administrator-clerk-treasurer, at the June 7 streets committee meeting.

Under Section E, the ordinance states, “if any village enforcement official determines that a village street, alley, public grounds or land dedicated for public use is obstructed or encumbered, he shall issue a written notice to the property owner of the premises which adjoin the obstructed public area directing that the obstruction be removed within 24 hours.”

Under Section F (2), the ordinance states, “the failure of the village clerk-treasurer to record such claim or to mail such notice or the failure of the owner to receive such notice shall not affect the right to place the village expense on the tax rolls for unpaid bills for abating the obstruction as provided for in this section.”

At issue is a tree in the boulevard by Dobbs’ house that was struck by lightning one evening, was determined to pose an imminent danger by the police officer on duty that evening and was taken down the next morning by Shackleton Tree Service.

Streets committee members toured several areas of the village prior to meeting at the village hall June 7, including Maple Street.

The officer on duty thought the tree posed a danger, Niggemann said.

Dobbs says she does not believe the tree was posing an imminent danger.

Niggemann asked the village’s attorney, Christina Mayer, to research the issue, and Mayer pointed out the authority exists to determine the tree posed a danger and could be removed under the 6-2-5 section of the village’s ordinances.

When asked what she wanted from the village, Dobbs said the stump needed to be removed, and she did not want to replace the section of sidewalk by the stump.

Several houses on Maple Street do have sidewalks, including Dobbs’ house, but sidewalk has not been installed at all of the homes on Maple Street.

Shackleton Tree Service intends to remove the stump, although the timing has been delayed because a family member has been in the hospital, said Rand Bates, director of public works.

The cost to take down the tree and remove the stump is $1,055, he said.

Dobbs told the street committee her son had called the police department to report the lightning strike and that she had wanted a police report so she could turn the claim over to her insurance company.

The agent for her insurance company wanted a police report and pictures, she said.

The police officer did not write a report, Dobbs said.

An estimate had been obtained last year for taking down the tree, and streets committee members asked when Dobbs had intended to move forward with removing the tree.

“When I have the money,” Dobbs replied.

If the village board decides to invoice Dobbs for the cost of removing the tree, several options are available, Niggemann said.

Dobbs can pay the bill; she can turn it into her insurance company; she can take it to an attorney; or the amount can be put on the tax roll, she said.

Dobbs thinks the village was wrong in the way the situation was handled, said Carey Davis, village trustee and chair of the streets committee.

“Could it have been approached differently?” Davis asked.

Bates said when he was talking to Dobbs the next morning, Shackleton was already on the way.

“Why didn’t you say, ‘hold on a minute,’?” he asked.

When Niggemann asked if a 50-50 split on the cost would be acceptable, Dobbs said, it was a “good start.”

The village’s ordinances also require damaged sidewalks to be replaced.

Dobbs said her sidewalk does not need to be replaced because “it goes nowhere.”

Mark Halpin, village trustee and a member of the streets committee, wondered if it would be acceptable to Dobbs to remove the damaged the section of sidewalk and leave the rest of the sidewalk.

The streets committee approved a motion to recommend to the village board a 50-50 split on the cost of removing the tree, taking out the section of sidewalk that was damaged, filling in the hole with black dirt so it can be seeded to grass and fixing the holes in the yard created by removing the tree.

Village Trustee Annie Schieber also serves on the streets committee.

Legion Drive

In other business, the streets committee discussed Legion Drive and the possibility of paving it with crushed blacktop.

Legion Drive runs from Main Street, directly south of the railroad tracks, west to RKR Screen Printing.

Members of the streets committee along with Niggemann and the reporter from the Colfax Messenger toured Legion Drive as well.

Fixing Legion Drive does not fix the problem with dusty conditions because the area directly in front of RKR and the area where Woods Run Forest Products trucks drive to get to Legion Drive are not part of the village’s street, Niggemann said.

If the street is paved with regular asphalt, on a hot day, the asphalt will sustain damage from short turning by the trucks, Bates said.

Davis suggested putting down ground asphalt and also a concrete pad on the part of the street next to where rail cars are loaded.

The streets committee approved a motion to obtain estimates that will be brought back to the committee for ground asphalt from Main Street to the railroad tracks, and from the tracks to the end of the street as well as an estimate for concrete from Main Street to the railroad tracks.