Skip to content

Dunn County third in line for another judge

By LeAnn R. Ralph

MENOMONIE — Clara Minor, the Dunn County Clerk of Courts, has been saying it for years: Dunn County needs a third judge.

And now it looks as though Dunn County could, indeed, receive a third judge.

The Honorable Scott R. Needham, a St. Croix County circuit court judge and the Chief Judge for 10th District in Wisconsin, spoke to the Dunn County Board at the May 21 meeting about the very real possibility of adding another judge.

Minor and the Honorable Rod Smeltzer have done an amazing job of operating Dunn County with only one judge and supplementing with reserve judges since the retirement of Judge William Stewart last November, Judge Needham said.

Dunn County District Attorney James Peterson was elected in April to fill Judge Stewart’s position and will be starting his duties as judge this summer, he noted.

Be that as it may, Dunn County still has enough of a caseload to warrant a third judge, Judge Needham said.

The preferred method for adding a judge in any particular county is for the initiative to come from the state, for the state to assess the need for additional judges on a statewide basis, and then for the state Legislature to approve legislation to add judges in particular counties, Judge Needham explained.

Any county could appeal to a local legislator and have that person start an initiative for legislation to add a judge, but it is better for the state to assess the need in all of the counties, he said.

Three criteria that are considered for adding another judge include the caseload in the county, whether the county has an available courtroom for another judge and local support from the county board in the form of a resolution supporting legislation for additional judges, Judge Needham said.

Dunn County had the foresight to add another courtroom when the judicial center was built in 1998, so space for another judge is not an issue, he said.

Third

Patrick Brummond, the acting District Court Administrator, talked about Dunn County’s judicial workload.

The number of cases handled by the two judges in Dunn County is enough cases for 2.6 judges, Brummond said.

Dunn County is third in the state in terms of workload per judge and is right in line behind Jackson County and Wood County, he said.

A time study that was completed indicated that each felony takes 113 minutes, but Brummond cautioned county board members to remember that while some felonies are dismissed, others go to a trial that can last for days.

A third judge for Dunn County has been in discussion since 2006, but Dunn County was not ranked at number three until now, he said.

If a bill to add other judges, including a third judge for Dunn County, is approved during the next legislative session in 2015, then nomination forms could be circulated the following December, the new judge for Dunn County would be elected in April of 2016 and would then start his or her duties in August of 2016, Brummond explained.

Fewer cases

One county board member asked about reducing the number of court cases instead of adding a judge.

Local law enforcement could write fewer citations, Brummond said.

The Dunn County Sheriff’s Department and the police departments in Dunn County’s municipalities also do fewer arrests for burglaries, thefts, drug possession, drug trafficking and sexual assaults.

Fewer citations and fewer arrests for serious crimes would not, however, increase the safety of Dunn County residents, Brummond said.

Children in need of protective services takes up more court time in Dunn County than felonies and misdemeanors, Minor said.

Every county is different, and in St. Croix County, mental commitments have increased dramatically, and child support enforcement also has increased, Judge Needham said.

The state of Wisconsin will pay the salary for an additional judge and for an additional court reporter.

Dunn County would be responsible for providing a courtroom, supplies, and sufficient room for support personnel.

The Dunn County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a resolution supporting legislation to create additional judgeships and urging the state Legislature and Governor Scott Walker to create a third branch of the Circuit Court for Dunn County.

Other business

In other business, the Dunn County Board of Supervisors:

• Learned that as of mid-April, the winter maintenance budget of $928,000 was nearly $92,000 over budget, meaning that Dunn County has spent more than $1 million on winter maintenance so far this year — and that still leaves next fall.

• Approved a rezone in the Town of Red Cedar from agricultural residential to commercial for nearly eight acres for Bruce and Teresa Olson to use a farm building to host events, such as weddings and family gatherings.

• Approved an amended intergovernmental agreement with the City of Menomonie to provide HazMat team services outside of the county. Dunn County has had an agreement with Menomonie since 1993. Under the old agreement, Menomonie could not go outside of Dunn County. Amending the agreement will allow the Menomonie HazMat team to help surrounding counties, similar to a mutual aid agreement.

• Approved a resolution requesting that the Wisconsin Counties Association oppose any state legislation seeking to extend the diminishing asset rule. Extending the rule to property that has been registered for mineral rights would restrict or possibly prevent the ability of local government to regulate mining activity, even if new technologies or the discovery of health impacts would justify changes in local regulations.