Boyceville ambulance district board facing hostilities
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
BOYCEVILLE — The Boyceville Community Ambulance District Board is facing a situation that is volatile and hostile.
Town board members texting veiled threats and violating the state’s Open Meetings Law.
Residents speaking during public comments, sounding ugly, fearful and bullying.
Mutual aid agreements among fire departments and ambulance services violated.
Emergency medical technicians attempting to extort and manipulate the ambulance district board, saying they will come back to work if the board gives in to their demands.
An interim ambulance service director using expletives and obscene language in official written communications with other EMTs.
The Boyceville Community Ambulance Service, like many other ambulance services in the area, the state and the country, is experiencing difficulty finding EMTs.
Under state law, Wayne Dow, director of the ambulance service, can respond to a call with the ambulance as a first responder, but the patient cannot be transported unless there is another EMT or first responder to drive the ambulance.
For a certain portion of the time, Dow is the only EMT on duty at the Boyceville ambulance service.
During his report to the Boyceville Community Ambulance District Board at the January 12 meeting, Dow stated there had been 16 calls since the last meeting of the ambulance district board.
Boyceville transported six patients, Menomonie transported four patients, Glenwood City transported one patient, and Colfax transported one patient. Two of the 16 calls refused the ambulance service, one call did not have a patient and one call was for a fire standby.
Service agreements are different than mutual aid.
Mutual aid constitutes an agreement among various departments to provide equipment and personnel when one department needs help.
A service agreement is between two departments that allows the responding department to invoice the department that needs help.
In addition to being part of the mutual aid network, Boyceville has service agreements with Glenwood City, Colfax and Menomonie to respond to calls when Boyceville cannot transport a patient.
So far in the month of January, there were two people on duty at the Boyceville ambulance service 64.2 percent of the time, there was one person on duty 35.8 percent of the time, and Boyceville had not been listed as “out of service,” Dow said.
New Haven
During the public comments portion of the Boyceville ambulance board meeting January 12, Tom Schoonover, a supervisor on the New Haven Town Board, said the Town of New Haven was asking for the resignation of Wayne Dow, director of the Boyceville ambulance service.
Jeff Carlsrud, also a supervisor on the New Haven Town Board, was in the audience as well.
Marv Prestrud, town chair, represents the township on the ambulance board.
The motion made at the New Haven Town Board meeting on January 11 asking for Dow’s resignation was not a legal motion under the state’s Open Meetings Law and Roberts Rules of Order.
The Boyceville ambulance service was listed on the agenda as a town board discussion item but not as an action item.
Prestrud, as town chair, did not recognize the motion made by Carlsrud and seconded by Schoonover.
Carlsrud interrupted Prestrud, presided over the motion himself, and he and Schoonover voted in favor.
Since Carlsrud and Schoonover were at the ambulance district meeting in the audience and the Town of New Haven is a member of the ambulance district, under state law, they were conducting official business.
According to state law, the presence of Carlsrud and Schoonover in the audience constituted an official town board meeting, since they were two members of a three member board and were a quorum, and a meeting notice should have been posted or published.
To be legal, a meeting notice must be published on the town’s website and posted at the town hall, or posted in three locations in the township, or published in a newspaper.
The Tribune Press Reporter was unable to find a meeting notice on the Town of New Haven website indicating a quorum of the board would be at the ambulance district meeting, although a meeting notice could have been posted in three locations around the township.
A meeting notice was not published in the Tribune on January 12 or January 5.
Schoonover also demanded to know how long the service would be able to continue and was disgusted when none of the ambulance district board members answered him.
Under state law, a board can decide whether public comment is received.
Public comment is intended for members of the public to make comments on topics of their choosing but is not intended to be a “back and forth” with board members.
Not difficult
New Haven residents attended the town board meeting on January 11 and “are not happy with the ambulance service,” Carlsrud said.
The ambulance service has been in chaos for nine months, but managing an ambulance service is not a difficult job, he said, adding that the service has not been improving.
Ten letters had been received from 10 former EMTs with the Boyceville service who said they would return to work if there is a change in leadership, Carlsrud said.
“Maybe someone else should try it,” he said, in reference to managing the ambulance service.
Mutual aid
The concern is public safety, said Cory Green, Boyceville fire chief.
A staffed ambulance is needed at a fire scene, and at a recent fire near Connorsville at a trailer house, it was unknown if the residence was occupied at the time of the call for the fire department, he said.
Dow was able to respond to the fire with the ambulance but did not have another EMT or first responder with him.
Dow and another firefighter certified as a first responder could have transported a patient if necessary, and it would have been up to the incident commander at the fire to reassign a firefighter to the ambulance service should the need arise for transport.
In response to a question from an ambulance district board member, Dow said there are usually first responders who respond to a fire or accident scene — sheriff’s department deputies often act as first responders — but that he generally does not know ahead of time who will arrive as a first responder or how many first responders may end up at the scene.
Boyceville was operating off the Mutual Aid Box Alarm System (MABAS) agreement for the fire, Green said during his public comments.
As part of the mutual aid agreement with surrounding fire departments and ambulance services, dispatch paged Glenwood City for mutual aid, he said.
In rural areas where there may not be enough volunteers to respond to a fire or an ambulance call, mutual aid agreements are crucial to being able to provide service for residents.
Because fire departments and ambulance services rely on mutual aid agreements, calls to which they respond as mutual aid are not invoiced.
It has been the observation of the Tribune Press Reporter concerning mutual aid that while a service may give more mutual aid than is received in one particular year, the next year, that service may receive more mutual aid than it gives.
Invoice
The Boyceville ambulance board received an invoice from Glenwood City for $500 for providing mutual aid at the Connorsville fire.
Dow recommended that the Boyceville ambulance district not pay the invoice and that it should be forwarded to the fire district.
Earlier in the meeting, after going over the invoices for the month and paying the bills, the ambulance district board followed Dow’s recommendation about the invoice.
No information was given at the meeting as to why Glenwood City invoiced for mutual aid.
Green, who turned out not to be the incident commander at the Connorsville fire, said the fire department “needs to know where things stand when firefighters lives are on the line.”
Carrie Green said she worries about her husband as fire chief and that firearms were known to be kept at the residence involved in the recent fire.
Ammunition could have exploded in the fire and injured the firefighters, she said, noting that she considers all of the firefighters to be members of her family.
Strong opinions
Pete Score, representative for the Town of Sheridan and chair of the ambulance district board, said he is aware there are “strong opinions out there.”
Score said he had received a telephone call from Shanna Knops, who serves as EMT for the Boyceville ambulance service, about the “hostile situation” at the ambulance service but that they would have to disagree about the cause for the hostile situation.
E-mail messages from the former interim director of the ambulance service about the hiring process for the director were found on the ambulance service e-mail system, Score said.
The ambulance district board conducted interviews March 30, and it was a unanimous vote to hire Wayne Dow as the director, he said.
According to the e-mails, the other two candidates interviewed were Andrew Kissh, interim director, and Shanna Knops.
Kissh and Knops were both captains with the ambulance service at the time.
The e-mail messages were sent to all of the EMTs that were with the ambulance service at that time, except Dow, Score said.
Score also read a text message that had been sent to Prestrud from New Haven supervisor Schoonover.
Schoonover and Carlsrud have asked Prestrud to “step down.”
The text message indicated that if Prestrud did not step down, “tomorrow night will be worse than tonight,” and Prestrud was urged to “give it some more thought for your own good.”
“Tomorrow night” was referring to the ambulance district board meeting.
During the New Haven Town Board meeting the evening before, Prestrud had reported that he had received a threat telling him if he “did not resign tonight” they would “get him with a lynch mob.”
The dozen or so EMTs who resigned from the Boyceville ambulance service last April resigned in protest because they did not want the ambulance district board to hire Dow as the ambulance service director.
Dow grew up in Boyceville and is a retired paramedic who served with Dubuque Fire and Rescue in Dubuque, Iowa, for 24 years. He served for 14 years as the EMS supervisor and the ambulance service director.
Dubuque has a population of 60,000, and the Dubuque fire department has a Class 2 Insurance Services Office (ISO) rating. ISO classes range from 1 to 10, with a rating of 10 being considered as having no fire department service at all.
The EMTs, who announced that they intended to resign after the ambulance district board had formally adjourned the April 14, 2021, meeting, said they were resigning because the board had not listened to them and had not hired the director they wanted.
A member of the ambulance district board gave copies of the e-mail messages to the Tribune Press Reporter.
In an e-mail message dated April 2, 2021, Kissh wrote that he felt, “we needed to make sure that the BCAD Board was made very much aware of what their decision was going to do to the service and the community.”
Eau Claire
Earlier in the e-mail message, Kissh had been upset about the Boyceville ambulance district board’s decision to have a retired battalion chief from the Eau Claire Fire Department help them with the hiring process and in interviewing candidates for the chief’s position.
The people who serve on the Boyceville ambulance district board are town board chairs or town board members in the municipalities served by the Boyceville ambulance service.
Kissh wrote, “The board admitted to not knowing what it really takes to run an ambulance so they brought in an ‘expert.’ The ‘expert,’ and I do use that term loosely, was a retired battalion chief from the Eau Claire Fire Dept. who has been retired for a number of years and couldn’t tell me the last time he was even on an ambulance much less providing any type of patient care.
“The ‘expert’ was from a big city career department where the[y] have a city hall and all sorts of admin type staff, a budget that is flexible and a line of applicants hoping to get hired on.
“The BCAD Board never even thought about talking to the any of you, the people who actually give of themselves time and time again, who make themselves available just to ensure we can get a rig out the door. They never thought to talk to the people that have to deal with the chief, that have to depend on the chief to make sure there are supplies in the trucks and that the station is operational. They never talked to the members of OUR organization that DO THE WORK!”
Special meeting
Kissh went on to write that after he had sent an e-mail message announcing the board’s decision to hire Dow, which was dated March 30, he had received confirmation from six EMTs who planned to resign and that he now had confirmation of 11 who planned to resign.
Since so many EMTs were planning to leave the ambulance service, Kissh said he had called for a special meeting of the ambulance district board.
“During this meeting, the board will go into close[d] session. For the first time in my life, some pain in the ass interim chief put a caveat on the agenda for the meeting stating that select, invited EMS personnel will be allowed to stay, witness and participate in the discussion that will happen during the closed session.”
It is not clear from the e-mail message under which state statute dealing with personnel that the ambulance district board was planning to go into closed session.
Closed sessions are allowed under state law for personnel issues, such as when a board is considering disciplinary action or will be discussing sensitive information that could harm the reputation of an employee.
Kissh goes on to write, “Every one of you is invited. The board needs to hear from you. They need to know they f*cked up by not talking to you … I encourage everyone to show up and show this board that we are a family and we support each other.
“I don’t know if this will change anything. I received a call right after Val [Windsor, clerk-treasurer for the ambulance district] informed the board members that I was calling for a special meeting from Gib the board president. [Gilbert Krueger, Boyceville village president at the time and chair of the ambulance board]. I will not go into the specifics of what Gib said to me.” Kissh went on using foul language and four letter words against Krueger.
Kissh concluded the e-mail message by admitting that he also is not an expert at leading an ambulance service and that he is “not the most professional or always politically correct … But I have a damn good team, and I’m not willing to watch all of our hard work, to keep that service going through all of the struggles over the last year and a half, go right down the f*cking toilet overnight.”

