$40,000 Riverview storm sewer repair an “all or nothing” proposition
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
COLFAX — It was a matter of “all or nothing.”
The Colfax Village Board decided upon “all” at the February 8 meeting for the repair of the Red Cedar River bank below Riverview Avenue and the installation of a new storm sewer system.
The two options are “do nothing” or do the $40,000 project, said Lisa Fleming a civil engineer and manager of municipal services at Ayres Associates Inc.
If the village board decided to do a $5,000 “patch project,” then the village would be on its own because Ayres would have to remain “hands off” to avoid jeopardizing Ayres’ license to operate, Fleming said.
The first step is to apply for a permit from the state Department of Natural Resources to repair the river bank, and approval of the permit from the DNR usually takes 30 to 45 days, she said.
Ayres will propose the design, apply to the DNR for the permit, and then proceed with the bidding process so that by the time the village board is ready to award a bid, the permit will be issued, Fleming said.
The project will consist of restoring the river bank and replacing the existing corrugated pipe with a manhole at river level, she said, noting that the estimate for construction is $30,000, and the engineering cost will be $9,200.
The Village of Colfax is well acquainted with Fleming’s work as a civil engineer.
Fleming has designed street projects and has been the construction manager on those projects for many years and is known for her common-sense and cost-effective approach to solving problems.
In a letter to the village board that accompanied documents Fleming e-mailed for the village board’s February 9 meeting packet, Fleming wrote: “The bank in the current conditions has eroded and is extremely unstable. The grade difference from the street to the outfall of the pipe also generates a high velocity of the stormwater discharge, even in a small storm, We have to engineer the solution for those velocities in larger storms or the effort put into this pipe replacement is wasted. Compounding the entire problem is the area of the manhole and discharge are right below a bridge on the outside curve of the river, the worst place for bank stabilization. During high water this is the area where the river too has the highest velocity as it goes through the bridge and makes the slight turn.”
Permit
Scott Gunnufson, village president, asked if it is possible for the village to obtain a DNR permit without actually committing to completing the project.
There is a fee for the permit, which is probably several hundred dollars, and then there is the cost for Ayres to engineer the stormwater drainage and the repair to the river bank, Fleming said.
A DNR permit is typically valid for 12 to 18 months before it would have to re-issued. And once a permit is issued, the DNR is going to have the expectation that the project will be completed, she said.
Village Trustee Carey Davis brought up the repair to the Red Cedar River bank near the wastewater treatment lagoons to keep the river from washing out the lagoons.
Construction to stabilize the river bank by the lagoons is expected to take place perhaps as soon as this summer and has involved the village applying for a Community Development Block Grant as well as design of the $1.6 million project by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
Between the CDBG funds and money available through the Army Corps of Engineers, the lagoon bank project will cost the village about $40,000.
Davis said he was of the opinion the repair of the river bank below Riverview Avenue should be done properly and should be completed as soon as possible.
If the river bank had been repaired by the wastewater treatment lagoons years ago, it would have cost considerably less than the millions it will cost now, he said.
Manhole
The new storm sewer draining from Riverview will involve a 17 to 20 foot deep manhole at river level with a backstop, Fleming said.
At times, when the river is high during snowmelt in the spring or after a heavy rain, the manhole will most likely be submerged, and it might back up onto the street above, she said.
If the manhole does back up onto the street, the water will eventually drain away, Fleming said.
Ayres designed a manhole project on Otter Creek in Eau Claire County that required two manholes, and the Riverview storm sewer may require two manholes as well, she said.
Monitoring
After the Riverview storm sewer project is completed, it will have to be monitored closely for two years, especially in the spring and after a heavy rain, Fleming said.
According to Fleming’s letter, “The option presented will provide the best chance for stabilization of the area for years to come. Note I say chance. The most vulnerable time for this area is right after it is installed. It will not have had time to completely stabilize and establish the vegetation it will need to armor itself. We believe it will be a very good chance it will get through the first year, but extremely high water or rainfall could impact it. It is important to note it will not fail all at once, but will start to fail with small rivulets or erosion problems. It will be important to monitor the area after each rainfall and flood event for the next two years, and if there are weak spots showing, that they be fixed immediately.”
The letter goes on to say, “Erosion is one of the toughest problems to solve in civil engineering. How much money do you throw at the project to make sure it will never erode again (think poured retaining wall sitting on piling driven below the scour line dollars) as opposed to the option being offered. We want to provide the village with the best possible solution for the most reasonable price that will meet the needs of the project. We want to provide you with the realistic expectations of what needs to happen for the project to be successful after the contractor has completed his work.”
Once grass and other vegetation is well established on the river bank, then the repair of the river bank is much more likely to hold, Fleming told the village board.
Timeline
Village Trustee Mark Halpin asked about the timeline for the Riverview storm sewer project.
The exact timeline will depend on the contractor, but not before spring run-off, Fleming said.
Because Viking Drive will be impacted by the Riverview Avenue street project, the work will have to be coordinated with the school district and the bus schedule, as well as the access to Viking Drive for emergency vehicles, said Lynn Niggemann, village administrator-clerk-treasurer.
Construction on the project will have to be done during the summer after school is out, she said.
The best time to do the project would be June or early July to allow the repair of the river bank to be completed before there are any heavy summer rain storms, Fleming said.
The Colfax Village Board unanimously approved amending the agreement with Ayres Associates for engineering services related to the Riverview Avenue, High Street and Dunn Street projects to include $9,200 for the design of the Riverview storm sewer and river bank repair.
The Riverview Avenue project (from High Street to Viking Drive) includes 500 feet of street and curb and gutter, storm sewer reconstruction, water main reconstruction and sanitary sewer reconstruction for a total estimated construction cost of $240,300.
The High Street project (from Riverview Avenue to Oak Street) will include 100 feet of street and curb and gutter, storm sewer reconstruction, water main reconstruction and sanitary sewer reconstruction for a total construction cost of $96,100.
The Dunn Street project, which will cost an estimated $87,500 for engineering fees and construction, will involve 215 feet of sanitary sewer extension and pavement reconstruction but does not include water main or storm sewer.

