Colfax withdraws from Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
COLFAX — If all goes according to plan, the Village of Colfax will soon be operating its own solid waste and recycling program.
The Colfax Village Board approved moving forward with withdrawing from Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling at the August 10 meeting.
In order to operate the village-owned collection site west of Colfax currently operated by Dunn County, the village must also apply to the state Department of Natural Resources to become a Responsible Unit by the deadline of October 1.
Municipalities that are members of Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling have a deadline of August 19 to inform the county if they plan to withdraw from the program.
Under the agreement with the county, municipalities must give 120 days’ notice of their intention to withdraw.
The Colfax Village Board, along with representatives from the Towns of Colfax, Otter Creek, Grant, Tainter and Red Cedar, met August 6 at the Colfax fire station to discuss how to address the problems with Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling, said Scott Gunnufson, village president.
At issue is an increase in the per capita fee of $23 this year to somewhere in the range of $60 to $80 per person next year — or possibly more.
Morgan Gerk, director of Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling, has been unable to provide a good estimate for the 2021 per capita fee because of several factors, including not knowing which municipalities will stay with the county program and not knowing for certain whether the $330,000 borrowed from the county’s general fund will have to be paid in full next year.
The Town of Red Cedar has already notified Dunn County that the township is withdrawing from the county program.
Representatives from the Town of Red Cedar attended the Colfax meeting to provide information about their intentions to become a Responsible Unit to run their own solid waste and recycling program.
For decades, the solid waste and recycling per capita fee Dunn County has charged has been artificially low, subsidized by the sale of recyclable materials.
Within the past few years, the bottom has fallen out of the recycling market so that in some cases, the county has ended up paying to dispose of the recyclable materials rather than turning a profit.
Increase
The increase in the per capita fee, at a minimum, would mean the Village of Colfax would have to find at least another $40,000 in the budget for solid waste and recycling in addition to the $25,000 paid this year.
The village is already levying up to the state-imposed revenue limit and does not have another $40,000 in the budget to spare, said Lynn Niggemann, village administrator-clerk-treasurer, at the August 10 village board meeting.
The property tax levy can only increase by so much, and if it goes over the limit, “that’s against the law,” she said.
The village could hold a referendum to ask village residents about exceeding the state-imposed levy limit, but it is too late for the November election to get on the ballot, and Colfax would be stuck paying the increased per capita to Dunn County for 2021, Niggemann said.
No one at the village board meeting mentioned it, but there is also the possibility that village residents would not approve a referendum question asking to exceed the revenue limit for solid waste and recycling expenses.
In past referendum questions, Wisconsin voters have shown a tendency to approve exceeding the levy limit for building projects but are less likely to approve exceeding the levy limit for operational expenses, perhaps because there is a finite amount attached to a building project but operational expenses recur year after year.
Tons
Prior to the Colfax joint municipal meeting, Niggemann gathered information from the county about how many tons of solid waste and recycling are hauled from the Colfax site each year so she could calculate a rough estimate of operating costs.
A “pull” fee is charged per Dumpster, along with a tipping fee per ton.
The more people there are in the program, the more tons that will be hauled from the collection site, the more expensive the program will be, but there will also be more people to help pay for the program, Gunnufson said.
Presumably, people from the Village of Colfax, along with people from the Towns of Colfax, Grant, Otter Creek and Tainter, are the people who are using the Colfax collection site now.
Niggemann’s rough estimate of an annual operating cost for the Colfax site is around $135,000.
The population of the Village of Colfax and the Towns of Colfax, Grant, Otter Creek and Tainter is nearly 5,700.
Based on the population and the estimated operating cost, the per capita fee for Colfax to operate the site would be about $23 per person per year.
Niggemann’s estimate does not include the cost of purchasing the equipment at the collection site from Dunn County.
Gary Stene, village trustee and also a supervisor on the Dunn County Board, noted that all of the municipalities participating in the program own the equipment, “so if you buy it, you are buying it from yourself.”
On the other hand, Dunn County “will want to maximize the assets,” he said.
Decision
At the August 10 Colfax Village Board meeting, Niggemann suggested the village board might want to hold a special meeting the following week to vote on whether to withdraw from the county program.
Gunnufson pointed out that if the village board did not make a decision August 10, the surrounding townships would not know if they had an option of going with the village.
All of the town boards in the surrounding townships planned to meet the week of August 10.
Stene pointed out that the county board has approved a referendum question for the November ballot asking voters to approve $1 million per year for five years for Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling.
If the referendum does not pass, then Dunn County will be getting out of the solid waste and recycling business, Stene said.
If the referendum passes, then all Dunn County residents, no matter whether they are part of the county’s solid waste and recycling program, will pay toward the $1 million, Niggemann said.
Responsible Unit
All municipalities in Wisconsin must either be their own Responsible Unit or must belong to the Responsible Unit of another municipality.
Under the current system, most of the municipalities in Dunn County are part of the county’s Responsible Unit.
Being a Responsible Unit refers to recycling. A rural Responsible Unit, with a population of less than 5,000, is required by the DNR to collect at least 82.4 pounds of recyclables per person per year.
An urban Responsible Unit, with a population of over 5,000, and an average density of 70 people per square mile, must collect at least 106.6 pounds of recyclables per person per year.
The requirements of being a Responsible Unit include passing a recycling ordinance with fines for people who do not comply, setting up an education program to inform residents about recycling, establishing a complaint process, reporting on the number of complaints received, the number of warnings and citations issued and how the complaint was resolved, and reporting on the number of tons of recyclables collected.
The deadline to submit application materials to the DNR for becoming a Responsible Unit is October 1, and by January 1, the DNR will determine if the municipality can become a Responsible Unit, Niggemann said.
It was the consensus of the village board that since Colfax owns the collection site, the village should be the Responsible Unit.
After the October 1 deadline, the village might have to modify some of the documentation and paperwork, “but that’s the only thing that could hold us up,” Niggemann said.
After Colfax becomes the Responsible Unit and starts operating the Colfax collection site, recycling will be “different” and will become single stream, said Village Trustee Margaret Burcham.
Dunn County currently source separates recyclables, which is part of the reason why the program is expensive. The county receives more money for clean recyclables, but it also is labor intensive to hand sort the recyclables.
Under a single stream system, all recyclables would go into one collection box and would be sorted, by machine, at a materials recovery facility (also known as an MRF, pronounced “merf”).
Motion
The Colfax Village Board voted unanimously to leave the Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling Program.
Niggemann asked if it was the village board’s intention for her to write a letter to formally withdraw from Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling , to which the answer was, “yes.”
Voting in favor of the motion were Village President Scott Gunnufson and Village Trustees Margaret Burcham, Carey Davis, Mark Halpin, Anne Jenson, Logan Michels and Gary Stene.

