Dunn County judge finds probable cause and binds Styer over for trial
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — Dunn County Circuit Court Judge James Peterson has found probable cause and has bound over for trial Gary Styer, who is accused in his death of his father, Edward Styer of Colfax.
Styer appeared before Judge Peterson for a preliminary hearing February 13 with his attorneys, Liesel E. Nelson and Jeremiah Harrelson.
Styer, 51, is charged with one felony county of first degree intentional homicide, with the modifiers of use of a dangerous weapon and domestic abuse inflicting physical pain or injury, in the death of his 78-year-old father on January 15 at the Styer home south of Colfax.
Styer’s attorneys had subpoenaed Deputy Peter Forbes and Investigator Jacob Mack to testify at the preliminary hearing.
Judge Peterson said he had received a motion from the district attorney to quash the subpoenas for Forbes and Mack.
The defendant has a right to call witnesses at a preliminary hearing to offer testimony that would prove favorable to the defendant, Harrelson said.
Investigator Mack was in Eau Claire and had talked to Gary Styer the afternoon of January 15, and Deputy Forbes had discovered the body of Edward Styer, he said.
When asked why he had subpoenaed the deputy and the investigator, Harrelson noted other deputies, investigators and the Dunn County and Ramsey County medical examiners were listed in the criminal complaint, but they were not subpoenaed.
Deputy Forbes was a first responder to the scene, and Investigator Mack spoke to the defendant at the Eau Claire public library, “but I don’t see their relevancy for a preliminary hearing,” said Dunn County District Attorney Andrea Nodolf.
During a preliminary hearing, a witness or witnesses testify to establish the facts in the criminal complaint, and the judge uses the testimony to find probable cause that a felony has been committed.
If the defendant waives the preliminary hearing, the judge can establish probable cause from the criminal complaint.
The defense is trying to have a “mini trial” and wants to question the officers in an attempt at discovering evidence, Nodolf said.
The defense may call witnesses for a preliminary hearing, but the defense cannot do a deposition of witnesses at a preliminary hearing or bring evidence, Judge Peterson said.
A preliminary hearing is not a trial, and because it is not a trial, witnesses should be limited, he said.
McRoberts
Captain Scott McRoberts, field services captain with the Dunn County Sheriff’s Department, was the only person called as a witness during the preliminary hearing.
The sheriff’s department was contacted to do a welfare check on the information that Edward Styer “may or may not be alive,” Captain McRoberts said.
Deputy Forbes and Deputy Charles Pollock responded to the residence and discovered a man lying in bed in a first floor bedroom, with blood and blood spatters on the walls, a 2×4 piece of lumber near the bed with blood on it, and no signs of life, he said.
The man, who was identified as Edward Styer, had extensive damage to the head and there was extensive blood, Captain McRoberts said.
A provisional autopsy report from the Ramsey County assistant medical examiner listed the cause of death as multiple blunt force injuries to the head with multiple fractures, and that the manner of death was homicide, he said.
Gary Styer met with Dunn County Investigator Dan Westlund on January 16 and communicated by hand gestures and writing on paper, Captain McRoberts said.
Information from Gary Styer was consistent with law enforcement observations, he said.
Legal conclusion
When Deputy Forbes entered the residence, did he draw a conclusion whether Edward Styer’s death was a homicide? Harrelson asked McRoberts.
How is asking a witness whether someone else came to a legal conclusion relevant to a preliminary hearing? Judge Peterson asked.
The deputy has had years of experience. Did he draw a conclusion? Harrelson asked.
The deputies found the deceased, who was examined by a pathologist, who concluded death was by blunt force. Gary Styer told investigators he had hit Edward Styer multiple times and had left the 2×4 by the bed, Judge Peterson said, adding that he did not know what information Deputy Forbes would be able to provide in testimony to go toward the preliminary hearing.
The best that could be hoped for would be inconsistencies, but that would not be relevant at a preliminary hearing, he said.
Mack
Harrelson said he wanted to call Investigator Mack to the witness stand because no information was included in the complaint about Mack’s finding January 15 when he spoke with Gary Styer in Eau Claire.
Judge Peterson asked what specific information Harrelson was looking for in calling Investigator Mack to the witness stand.
The investigator can make an offer of proof. If only witnesses are heard on the information in the criminal complaint, then it does not establish probable cause, Harrelson said.
Additional direct evidence, more than what is in the criminal complaint, is necessary, especially in a case as serious as this, he said.
Judge Peterson said he was not going to allow additional witnesses and that Harrelson trying to find information he does not have “is discovery.”
The defense will have an opportunity later to find information the defense does not have now, the judge said.
The preliminary hearing is to find probable cause whether a felony has been committed, and the degree of homicide is not relevant now, Judge Peterson said.
Hearsay is allowed at a preliminary hearing, and Captain McRoberts is a supervisor of the deputies and investigators named in the criminal complaint, he said.
If additional witnesses can provide evidence that affects plausibility, that would be acceptable, but the court is not weighing and balancing testimony or inconsistencies, and proof beyond a reasonable doubt is not needed for a preliminary hearing, Judge Peterson said.
Additional witnesses must be able to provide information to rebut probable cause, he said.
Judge Peterson quashed the subpoenas for Deputy Forbes and Investigator Mack and said he was satisfied probable cause had been established.
Styer is scheduled for an arraignment hearing in Dunn County Circuit Court at 11:30 a.m. March 11 before Judge Peterson.
At the time of the preliminary hearing, Styer remained in custody on a $250,000 cash bail set on January 20.

