Dunn County Board discusses levy limits, highway funding with state legislators
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — The Dunn County Board met with state legislators from the area during a special Zoom meeting February 28 to discuss a variety of priorities, including the state’s levy limit law and generating more funding for highways.
Much of the county’s operating revenue comes from the property tax levy for a variety of services provided to the residents of the county, such as the sheriff’s department, human services, public health, veteran’s services, highways and county facilities, said Gary Stene, county board supervisor from Colfax and vice-chair of the county board.
In 2006, the state legislature passed a property tax levy limit law that restricts the increase in the levy limit to the percentage of net new construction, he said.
Whatever the intention of the law was, “the effect over time has been to strangle local governments (in their ability) to provide the services and programs demanded and deserved by its citizens,” Stene said.
Since the adoption of the levy limit law, the percentage of net new construction in Dunn County has been less than the increase in costs for goods and services, he said.
Although it has been a small difference from year to year, the cumulative effect has been to cause the county to fall farther and farther behind, Stene said.
The consequences are that Dunn County has had to spend from the reserves in the fund balance or to borrow money to help balance the budget, and borrowing money raises taxes for property owners, he said.
Dunn County has exhausted the reserves, and the fund balance is now down to the point where it is not recommended by good accounting practices to go any lower in order to maintain the county’s credit rating, Stene said, adding that the recommendation to maintain the fund balance is 35 percent of the operating budget.
Because of the lack of revenue, the county will have to consider reducing services or eliminating programs, and the cuts will affect the elderly, children’s support services, mental health issues, response time for emergencies, the maintenance schedule for public infrastructure and the livelihoods of county employees by reducing hours or layoffs, he said.
Helping or hurting?
Legislators should ask themselves, “who does the levy limit law serve?” Stene asked.
The rational may have been to protect the taxpayers by forcing local governments to spend down their fund balances, but “if so, those goals have been met. The law is now having the effect of hurting those same property owners that it was intended to protect,” he said.
“The fundamental flaw in the levy limit law is the assumption that new construction would keep pace or outstrip the increasing costs of services and programs. This has not happened,” Stene said.
The Dunn County Board is asking the state legislature to amend the levy limit law to also allow an increase in the property tax levy by the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index for the region where the county is located. If there is no increase in the net new construction, then the allowable increase in the levy would equal the increase in CPI for the region, he said.
“It is a request for a life preserver to help the county keep its head above water,” Stene said.
The Dunn County Board also is asking that the state legislature modify the annual levy limit to include exemptions for the cost of services and programs mandated by state law that cannot be fully funded with state appropriations and which require county appropriations, he said.
This should not be regarded as “a partisan issue,” but as “a people issue,” Stene said.
Highways
The roads in Dunn County and in rural Wisconsin “are in dire shape,” said Kelly McCullough, county board supervisor from Menomonie and chair of the highway committee.
McCullough said that when he started as chair of the highway committee, he was 42 years old, and the average cycle to rebuild roads in the county was 25 years.
“So, someone my age could reasonably expect to be driving on a road younger than they were,” he said.
Since then, the average cycle to rebuild a road has increased to 45 years, McCullough said.
The cost to pave a mile of road now “is a great deal more” than it was 12 years ago, and so is the cost of materials, equipment and staff, he said.
With the levy limit in place, the county cannot raise taxes enough to cover the increased costs, McCullough said.
One solution would be to increase the gas tax so it is at a comparable level with surrounding states, he said.
“No one likes to raise taxes,” McCullough said.
But when the issue of raising the gas tax is framed as being dedicated to fixing the roads, most people are okay with the idea, he said.
Over the last decade, the roads have gotten steadily worse “because Wisconsin has not fixed the funding problem,” McCullough said.
“Fundamentally, what people want is simple — to be able to drive safely on smooth roads that are clear of snow and the potholes and debris that slow traffic and damage their vehicles,” he said.
Senator Bernier
Senator Kathy Bernier (R-Chippewa Falls) (23rd Senate District) was one of the area legislators who attended the special meeting of the county board.
Senator Bernier noted that this would be her last legislative session on the joint finance committee because she has decided not to run for re-election.
She pointed out that it was her budget motion that had secured more funding for conservation departments in the counties, which had been a request made by Tom Quinn, county board supervisor from Downing and chair of the planning, resources and development committee.
Subsidized guardianship “was also my baby” and should be freeing up some money for the human services department, Senator Bernier said.
Diane Morehouse, county board supervisor from Menomonie and chair of the Dunn County Health and Human Services Board, had talked about the need for increases in funding for a variety of areas falling under human services.
The state has a projected budget surplus, “but in this uncertain world,” the surplus “may or may not pan out,” Senator Bernier said.
Dunn County should focus on mobilizing the Wisconsin Counties Association to promote important issues with the state legislature, she said.
The Fenwood Creek pilot project is working with reducing phosphorus loading in surface waters by having farmers plant cover crops between corn crops, Senator Bernier said.
The funding that is proposed requires results and is results-based to help deal with phosphorus and nitrate problems, she said.
More money also will be coming for broadband expansion, Senator Bernier said.
James Anderson, county board supervisor from Menomonie and chair of the Community Resources and Tourism committee, had talked about the need for broadband expansion.
The problem with broadband expansion is not necessarily money but having enough workers to bury the fiber optic cable, Senator Bernier said.
As for the levy limits, Senator Bernier said she has been an advocate for adjusting the levy limits and also suggested that an additional half a percent of sales tax could be used to increase revenue.
Senator Bernier urged the county board to pursue the request for more sales tax rather than increases through the levy limit law.
Regarding roads and transportation, Senator Bernier said she agreed that an increase in the gas tax would help.
It will not get any cheaper to build and maintain roads, she said.
Summerfield
State Representative Rob Summerfield (R-Bloomer) (67th Assembly District) noted that nursing home reimbursements will be an issue for the next 10 to 15 years.
Brian Johnson, county board supervisor from Colfax and chair of The Neighbors of Dunn County Committee, had talked about increasing the Medicaid reimbursement rate for nursing homes.
Representative Summerfield said that when his great-grandmother was in the nursing nome in the early 1990s, she had been private pay for a while, but that in the five or six years she lived there, she then went to Medicaid.
Now nursing home residents are all pretty much Medicaid reimbursement and there is little private pay, he said.
As for broadband expansion, Representative Summerfield said people should talk to their Internet Service Providers and community members to help build support for broadband grant applications.
If the inflation rate runs at 10 or 12 percent for the next few years, that will affect the state’s budget surplus and tax revenues, “so let’s take a slow approach,” he said.
The state is in good shape financially, but “there are storm clouds coming,” Representative Summerfield said.
Representative Clint Moses (R-Menomonie) (29th Assembly District) was unable to attend the meeting because of a prior Menomonie school board commitment, but a member of his staff said she had taken notes and would review the information with Representative Moses.
Senator Jeff Smith (D-Brunswick) (31st Senate District) joined the Zoom meeting part of the way through but did not have any comments to make and said he had had been unable to review the packet because he had been busy during the day moving his mother-in-law into a nursing home.

