DC PR&D considers new options for housing density in unzoned townships
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — The Dunn County Planning, Resources and Development Committee has started considering options to remedy complaints from unzoned townships concerning housing density in a proposed land division ordinance.
If density is a good tool for helping to protect the environment, then the question is how to engage the unzoned townships in a way to replace or complement density? said Mike Kneer, county board supervisor from Menomonie and a member of the PR&D committee, at the committee’s June 8 meeting.
The proposed ordinance establishes a residential density of one lot per eight acres in unzoned townships.
A density of one lot per eight acres does not mean a minimum lot size of eight acres.
A residential density of 8 to 1 is already established in Dunn County’s zoning ordinance for zoned townships.
One reason for establishing housing density is for the protection of groundwater.
A big concern from the county’s groundwater study is contamination of the groundwater when there is a cluster of septic systems where there are too many lots together, said Tom Quinn, county board supervisor from Downing and chair of the PR&D committee.
If there are too many lots clustered together, geologists say you will [emphasis on will] get contamination of the groundwater, he said.
Once again
The PR&D committee forwarded the proposed ordinance to the Dunn County Board for consideration at the May meeting, but after receiving complaints from unzoned townships in the county, asked the county board to send the ordinance back to the PR&D committee for further consideration.
Before forwarding the proposed ordinance to the Dunn County Board, the PR&D committee held a public hearing.
After publishing the proper notices for a public hearing, and after county staff contacted town clerks, realtors, surveyors and title companies, and after several articles were published in the Colfax Messenger and the Glenwood City Tribune about the proposed ordinance — no one attended the public hearing.
Under the proposed ordinance, a landowner in an unzoned township in Dunn County who owns 40 acres, for example, that he or she wishes to subdivide for residential development could divide the parcel into five lots (40 divided by 8 is 5) by certified survey map (CSM) over five years. The minimum lot size is one acre, so the parcel could be divided into four one-acre lots and one 36-acre lot.
Under the proposed ordinance, the 36-acre lot could not be subdivided again.
If a landowner in an unzoned township had 80 acres, and 40 acres of the 80 were wetlands that cannot be developed for residential, under the proposed ordinance, the landowner could put the density for the 40 acres of wetlands toward the 40 acres where houses could be built, said Gary Bjork, county board supervisor from Colfax and a member of the PR&D committee, at the June 8 meeting.
“That’s a good benefit for the unzoned townships,” he said.
Options
The PR&D committee discussed density during five or six meetings as the best way to meet the county’s strategic plan, noted Diane Morehouse, county board supervisor from Menomonie and a member of the PR&D committee.
Morehouse asked Kneer what he meant by “other approaches” to density.
Unzoned townships cannot rezone to residential to by-pass the density requirement, so some other mechanism would have to be in place, Kneer said.
In the zoned townships in Dunn County, a landowner can apply for a rezone of agricultural land to residential to increase the number of houses that could be built on a parcel.
David Bartlett, county board supervisor from Boyceville and chair of the county board, asked about requiring plat maps in unzoned townships in the proposed ordinance as a way to help protect the environment in the way that the housing density of 8 to 1 helps achieve environmental goals.
Would it be possible to come up with a way to have enough rules to keep the environment safe but still give unzoned townships the ability to go farther with a plat? he asked.
Plat maps require engineering plans, road plans and soil erosion plans, said Tom Carlson, county surveyor.
Under the existing land division ordinance, property owners can create four residential lots in five years by certified survey map.
Under the proposed ordinance, property owners could create five lots in five years by CSM.
If, for example, a property owner had 160 acres that he or she wanted to subdivide, under a density of 8:1, the property could be divided into 20 lots, but dividing it into 20 lots by CSM would take 20 years.
Landowners also have the option of dividing the property by a plat map, and depending on the size of the lots, could divide the property by county plat or state plat.
Using a plat map for the land division would allow the landowner to subdivide 160 acres into 20 lots all at once.
Town zoning
Would it be possible to include in the proposed ordinance that if the unzoned townships have town zoning, then the townships could do their own rezone for greater density? Bjork asked.
At the meeting in April with unzoned townships and county board supervisors, the unzoned townships said they wanted town zoning if the county would recognize town zoning, he said.
If a town has adopted town zoning, by state law, the county must recognize the town zoning, said Nick Lange, Dunn County corporation counsel.
Lange went on to say that it would be possible to craft language for the proposed ordinance to implement density with limitations in the unzoned townships, until the subdivision reaches a certain number of lots, and then have a plat requirement, along with language to make density inapplicable if the town has a zoning ordinance.
Lange also pointed out that a town zoning ordinance would actually have to be a zoning ordinance and not one paragraph stating that the zoning ordinance allows all landowners in the township to do whatever they want.
A town zoning ordinance should work well with the county’s plan to protect the environment, he said.
How many unzoned townships in Dunn County have their own town zoning? Morehouse asked.
Townships that have not adopted county zoning in Dunn County include the Towns of New Haven, Sand Creek, Elk Mound, Spring Brook, Eau Galle and Rock Creek.
“None,” said Lange, Carlson and several members of the committee.
“NONE?” Morehouse sounded quite surprised that none of the unzoned townships have their own zoning.
Joint approval
What if the county had a procedure in place for the joint approval by the PR&D committee and the town board in an unzoned township for subdivisions? Carlson asked.
Say that a developer wants to divide 40 acres into 17 lots instead of the five lots allowed under density of 8 to 1. If the town board approves of the developer’s plan, and the developer brings the plan to the PR&D committee for approval, and the PR&D committee approves, the parcel could be divided into 17 lots, he explained.
The approval procedure would strictly be on a case-by-case basis, with each request being considered on its merits, and would not require county board approval, Carlson said.
If the town board did not support the developer’s plan, then it would go no farther, he said.
“That’s an interesting alternative,” Morehouse said.
Current plat
The Town of Elk Mound currently has a plat submitted to the county for approval under the existing land division ordinance that is a triangle shaped piece of property on 620th Avenue between the railroad tracks and I-94, said Tony Christopherson, chair of the Town of Elk Mound.
The parcel is not suitable for farming, and the best use is for houses, he said, noting the PR&D committee has been talking about the need for affordable housing in the county.
The proposed ordinance would eliminate the option to develop that triangle shaped piece of property, Christopherson said.
The plan goes through the town plan commission and the town board to make sure the environment is protected, he noted.
Figuring out a way to continue with the option to subdivide parcels by plat map would work for the Town of Elk Mound and maybe for the Town of Spring Brook, Christopherson said.
And while it might not be true for unzoned towns in the corners of the county, the Town of Elk Mound and the Town of Rock Creek are seeing housing pressure, he said.
The preliminary plat in the Town of Elk Mound that is under review is 26 acres, Carlson said.
Under the housing density of 8:1 in the proposed ordinance, the 26 acres could only be divided into three lots. The current ordinance allows the property to be developed into 10 lots by a plat map, he said.
Carlson said he agreed with Christopherson — while the parcel is not the best for farmland, it is more suitable for housing.
The 10 lots will sell fast once they are recorded, but they would not be allowed under the proposed ordinance, Carlson said, noting that he expects to bring the preliminary plat to the PR&D committee at the next meeting in two weeks.
“It is a prime example of what would not be allowed under the current proposed ordinance,” he said.
Bartlett said he liked the idea of including plat maps in the proposed land division ordinance to allow more divisions of parcels in unzoned towns and which would still take environmental challenges into consideration.
PR&D committee members agreed that county staff should develop conceptual frameworks for the suggested options to see how they would work.
Lange said he would work on developing a list of desirable elements for each option along with the advantages and disadvantages.
“We will move forward on it,” Quinn said.
The Dunn County Planning, Resources and Development Committee meets on June 22.

