Skip to content

Maple Street resident wants village to pay for taking down tree struck by lightning

By LeAnn R. Ralph

COLFAX — A resident on Maple Street believes the village should pay for taking down a tree in the boulevard that was struck by lightning.

Jane Dobbs spoke to the Colfax Village Board at the May 22 meeting about a tree in the boulevard by her house on Maple Street that had been struck by lightning on a Wednesday evening.

By 7:30 the next morning, Shackleton Tree Service arrived to cut down the tree, but no one had told her that the tree was going to be cut down, Dobbs said.

Dobbs asked about the protocol for removing a tree on village property as opposed to private property and asked what is considered village property and what is private property.

Boulevards are owned by the landowner but they are controlled by the village, said Gary Stene, village president.

According to Chapter 4 of the village’s ordinances, “public property” means owned or controlled by the village, including public sites, parks, playgrounds, streets, alleys, sidewalks, boulevards and the terrace strip between the lot line and the curb or improved portion of any public way.

The ordinance states that the entire cost of abating any tree determined to be a public nuisance, “when done at the direction of the village forester, shall be borne by the village as to any growth, tree or shrub located upon property owned by the village.”

The ordinance also states, however, that the abating of a public nuisance tree located upon a terraced strip between the lot line and the curb shall be considered private property.

Section 6-2-4 of the ordinance defines “public nuisance” as any tree or shrub that interferes with the use of any public area; infected with a plant disease; infested with insects or pests; is injurious to public improvements or endangers the life, health, safety or welfare of persons or property.

No boulevard

Dobbs said no boulevard exists along Maple Street because there is no curb.

Stene said the area between the lot line and the street is considered to be the boulevard or a terraced area.

Dobbs insisted because there is no curb or no sidewalk, there is no boulevard, and she again asked about the protocol.

Lynn Niggemann, village administrator-clerk-treasurer, said she had received a call that the tree had been struck by lightning and could be hazardous to the health, safety and welfare of village residents.

Rand Bates, director of public works, said he had called Shackleton Tree Service about taking down the tree.

The officer on duty that night said the tree had been struck by lightning and was split, he said.

Dobbs insisted the tree was not split, was not hollow, and was not in imminent danger of coming down.

The village did not follow the protocol outlined in the ordinances for taking down trees, Dobbs said.

According to the ordinance, a forester must make the determination of whether a tree must come down. The property owner must be notified. A public hearing is then held about taking down the tree, and then there is a time period to allow the property owner to take down the tree. Removal of the tree is at the property owner’s expense.

Forester

The village ordinance makes a provision for a forester and defines the Village Forester as a person or village employee designated by the village board as authorized to carry out the provisions of Chapter 4.

Village Trustee Casey Rihn has been appointed as the Village Forester.

The ordinance does not refer to trees posing an imminent danger.

According to Section 6-4-5, Section D (3): “When the Forester shall determine with reasonable certainty that a public nuisance exists upon private premises, he/she shall immediately serve or cause to be served personally or by registered mail upon the owner of such property, if he/she can be found, or upon the occupant thereof, a written notice of the existence of such nuisance and of a time and place for a hearing, not less than 14 days after service of such notice, on the abatement action to be taken. Such notice shall describe the nuisance and recommend procedures for its abatement, and shall further state that unless the owner shall abate the nuisance in the manner specified in the notice, or shall appear at the hearing to show that such nuisance does not exist or does not endanger the health of trees in the Village, the Forester shall cause the abatement thereof at the expense of the property served. If the owner cannot be found, such notice shall be given by publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the Village.”

The ordinance goes on to say, “If after the hearing held pursuant to this subsection, it shall be determined by the village board that a public nuisance exists, it shall forthwith order the immediate abatement thereof. Unless the property owner abates the nuisance as directed within five days after such hearing, the Forester shall proceed to abate the nuisance and cause the cost thereof to be assessed against the property in accordance with the procedure provided in this section. The Forester may extend the time allowed the property owner for abatement work but not to exceed ten additional days.”

Sidewalk

Although sidewalk has not been installed the length of Maple Street, there is a sidewalk in front of Dobbs’ residence.

The tree roots were pushing up a section of sidewalk, Bates noted.

The sidewalk was that way for 15 years, since the house had been purchased, and “there was no imminent danger,” Dobbs said.

Niggemann said Dobbs had called the village office a year ago, and Niggemann had discussed the tree ordinance with Dobbs.

“Did not,” Dobbs said.

“You were aware the tree was your responsibility,” Niggemann said.

The village contracted with Shackleton, so the village should pay for taking down the tree, Dobbs said.

Niggemann pointed out the estimate from a year ago to take down the tree was a little over $1,000.

The village did not have a forester, and the ordinance says homeowners have ten days, Dobbs said.

Police Chief William Anderson said Dobbs should ask her neighbors how they would feel about the tree if it came down on their house.

“The tree was nowhere near coming down,” Dobbs said.

Officer Shipman was on duty. The tree was struck by lightning. The officer was in charge of the safety of the village, and more storms were coming, Police Chief Anderson said.

Payment

“What are you asking from the village?” Stene inquired.

The village did not follow the ordinance, so the village should pay for taking down the tree, Dobbs said, hinting that she had called an attorney about the situation.

“Do not threaten us,” Stene said.

Stene said he would refer the matter to committee and wanted to find an amicable way to resolve the situation.

Shackleton said the tree was not an imminent danger, Dobbs said.

The situation will not be solved this evening, Stene said.

“We will get an answer to you as soon as possible,” he said.

Village officials thought the tree was a danger, Niggemann said.

“The guy on duty made the call,” Stene said.

“You should say you’re wrong,” Dobbs said.

“We will, if we are,” replied Village Trustee Carey Davis.

Cost

According to the village’s ordinance, if the Village Forester determines that a tree must be taken down, the cost can be assessed to the property after following the procedure included in the ordinance.

According to Section 6-4-6, Section B:

“The cost of abating a public nuisance or spraying diseased trees located on private premises when done at the direction and under the supervision of the Forester shall be assessed to the property on which such nuisance tree or wood is located as follows:

“The Forester shall keep a strict account of the cost of such work or spraying and the amount chargeable to each lot or parcel and shall report such work, charges, descriptions of lands to which charged and names and addresses of the owners of such land to the Village Board on or before October 15 of each year.

“Upon receiving the Forester’s report, the Village Board, or a designated standing committee thereof, shall hold a public hearing on such proposed charges, giving at least 14 days advance notice of the time, place and purpose of such a hearing to interested persons by publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the municipality and by mail to the owner of each property proposed to be charged. Each property owner shall be notified of the amount proposed to be assessed against his premises and the work for which such charge is being made.

“After such hearing, the village board, or a designated standing committee thereof, shall affirm, modify and affirm or disapprove such assessments by resolution and shall cause a copy thereof to be published. Upon adoption and publication of such resolution, assessments made thereby shall be deemed final.

The village clerk-treasurer shall mail notice of the amount of such final assessment to each owner of property assessed at his last-known address, stating that, unless paid within 30 days of the date of the notice, such assessment will be entered on the tax roll as a tax against the property, and all proceedings in relation to the collection, return and sale of property for delinquent real estate taxes shall apply to such assessment.

“The village hereby declares that, in making assessments under this section, it is acting under its police power, and no damages shall be awarded to any owner for the destruction of any diseased or infested tree or wood or part thereof.”

According to Section 6-4-11: “Any person who receives a determination or order under this chapter from the village Forester and objects to all or any part thereof shall have the right to appeal …to the village board within seven days of receipt of the order, and the village board shall hear such appeal within 30 days of receipt of written notice of the appeal. After such hearing, the Village Board may reverse, affirm or modify the order or determination appealed from and the grounds for its decision shall be stated in writing. The Village Board shall, by letter, notify the party appealing the order or determination of its decision within ten days after the hearing. The village board shall file its written decision with the village clerk-treasurer.”