Skip to content

Dunn County asks state to close tax loophole for big-box stores

By LeAnn R. Ralph

MENOMONIE —  The Dunn County Board has approved a resolution asking the state legislature to close a tax loophole for big-box chain stores.

According to the resolution approved at the county board’s May 17 meeting, some big-box chain stores are successfully arguing that the assessed value of their stores for property tax purposes should be only half of the store’s actual value on the open market.

The chain stores are using what is known as the “Dark Store Theory” to argue that the assessed value of their new, thriving store should be based on a comparison to stores from a different market segment close by that are abandoned or vacant, according to the background information included with the resolution.

The problem with chain stores being assessed at half their market value is that the property tax burden is then shifted to homeowners and main street businesses.

The resolution urges the governor and state legislators to protect homeowners and small businesses from having more of the tax burden shifted to them by passing legislation that allows leases to be appropriately factored into the assessed value of leased properties.

The resolution also asks that the governor and state legislators require assessors to consider only those sales within the same market segment as comparable that have a similar highest and best use rather than similarly sized but vacant properties when using the comparable sale method to determine property valuation.

Homeowners in Wisconsin already pay more than 70 percent of the total statewide property tax levy, and if the state does not close the loophole used by chain stores to gain dramatic reductions in property taxes, the property tax burden will only continue to increase for homeowners, according to the background information.

Some lawsuits in Wisconsin have forced assessors to reduce the market value of thriving chain stores to half of the actual value on the open market, according to the background information.

Two times in the last two years, the Indiana State Legislature has passed bipartisan legislation that prohibits assessors from assessing the value of new chain stores the same as nearby abandoned stores in a different market segment. The Michigan legislature also passed similar legislation in May of 2016, according to the background information.

The resolution directs the county clerk to send a copy of the resolution to Governor Scott Walker, the Wisconsin Counties Association and to Dunn County’s legislative representatives with the request that they assist with legislation closing the loophole.