Skip to content

Off The Editor’s Desk – 4-6-2016

Hard to match the 1870-1970 boom!

In the St. Paul Pioneer Press Sunday paper of a week ago there was column penned by George Will called “The Rise and Fall of American Growth.” He referred to a 762-page book by Robert Gordon of the same name.

“The economic revolution of 1870 to 1970 was unique. No other era in human history, either before or since, combined so many elements in which the standard of living increased as quickly and in which the human condition was transformed so completely,” Gordon stated!

Hill notes that in 1870, “three necessities, food, clothing and shelter, absorbed almost all consumer spending.” In 1870 homes had no running water, or a way to remove that gray water from the home. No electricity or screens on the windows, so flies and other insects could fly from the manure pile and the barn into the home and on to the dinner table.

Wills goes on to mention that in 1879 Edison invented the light bulb and about three months later Karl Benz had the first working internal combustion engine. It brought to mind a 2012 TV series about “Men Who Made America.” I thought of Henry Ford, Alexander Graham Bell, Eastman, Vanderbilt, Carnegie, Morgan, Rockefeller, those who changed America and the world and made money, lots of it.

But I also came up with a few other names, like John Pemberton (Coca Cola); Levi Strauss (Pants); Elisha Graves Otis (Elevator brake, made possible the skyscrapers); Joseph Glidden (Barbed Wire); Ottmar Mergenthaler (Linotype); and J.I. Case (tractors made in Wisconsin); and many more.

According to Wills, “Today the inflation-adjusted median wage of American males is lower than in 1969 and median household income is lower than when this century began. If the growth rate since 1970 had matched that of 1920-1970, instead of being one-third of it, per capita GDP in 2014 would have been $97,300 instead of $50,600.”

Those famous people who made all that money also created millions of new jobs and that took the average family out of the three necessities into the world of our modern civilization.

“Labor participation of 16 to 64 year olds has been declining almost every single year since 1997 even as the population has increased,” according to Robert Romano, senior editor of Americans for Limited Government. He continued, “namely, because the decline in labor participation has coincided with the slowdown of the U. S. economy, which has not grown above an inflation-adjusted rate of four percent since 2000, and not above three percent since 2005.”

But what happened? I know what happened, the government happened. People started looking down on those who made a lot of money and the government, as far back as Teddy Roosevelt, started to pass laws that would control those business and factories. In 1913 the Sixteenth Amendment to the constitution was approved, which stated “Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on incomes.”

The government took their money, gave it to the masses and everyone was happy. In reality, no one is happy and the government created a society of receivers instead of producers and the government spent all the money that it collected and put us almost $20 trillion in debt.

Does that not sound like something familiar to you? Both Clinton and Sanders want to increase the tax on people with high incomes and Sanders will add a couple of bucks worth of taxes each week to all others. I like Cruz, he is proposing to do away with the IRS and have no income tax on incomes below $36,000 and a ten percent flat tax on incomes above that. Businesses would be taxed at 16 percent under his proposal.

Thanks for reading!     ~Carlton