DCSW&R recommends keeping transfer station for cold storage
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — The Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling Management Board is recommending that Dunn County keep the transfer station for cold storage rather than selling or leasing it for the collection of non-mandated recyclables.
Earlier this year, Dunn County received several letters of interest about buying or leasing the transfer station for collecting non-mandated recyclables or for using the facility for solid waste and recycling, said Paul Miller, county manager, at the DCSW&R board’s June 8 meeting.
During the public comments portion of the meeting, letters from Frank Bammert, chair of the Town of Menomonie, and Randy Knaack, mayor of the City of Menomonie, were read into the record.
Bammert and Knaack urged Dunn County to sell or lease the transfer station for non-mandated recyclables and not to use the facility for cold storage.
Bob Cook, chair of the Town of Red Cedar, brought e-mail messages from 10 town board chairs who agreed with Red Cedar that the transfer station should be sold or leased.
The Town of Red Cedar has curbside pickup and does not need the transfer station, but using the transfer station for non-mandated recyclables would be a benefit to other Dunn County residents, he said.
In addition, using the transfer station for cold storage would be a “poor fit” for the Dunn County Highway Department, he said.
Rats and mice love machinery, and wires, belts, tubing and upholstery will be chewed up and nested in. Dunn County needs the money, and there also is the matter of the 20 acres nearby, Cook said.
The City of Menomonie is doing fine with the solid waste site and private haulers and has started recycling for metal, used oil and furniture, but there is a need for non-mandated recycling, said Randy Eide, director of public works for the City of Menomonie.
Interested parties want to use the transfer station, and it would be a benefit to all Dunn County residents, he said.
There is a need for non-mandated recycling, and the transfer station is too far from the highway shop, said Deb Gotlibson, a supervisor on the Red Cedar Town Board and the township’s solid waste and recycling coordinator.
The county should consider the Requests for Proposals that were presented for use of the transfer station, she said.
Poison
In his letter to the DCSW&R board, Bammert said the county wanted to retain the transfer station as a way to “punish” the other municipalities for pulling out of the county program and forming their own Responsible Units for recycling.
Dunn County does not operate from a petty position to punish municipalities, Miller said.
Dunn County “has no interest in poisoning the well (in regard to) relationships with the municipalities,” he said.
What has happened is that a building inspection has revealed a substantial cost for bringing the transfer station up to code, Miller said.
Several months ago, Morgan Gerk, director of the county’s solid waste and recycling program, reported that the estimated cost for making repairs to the transfer station would be in the several hundred thousand dollar range.
Even if the company leasing the transfer station absorbs the cost of repairs, that does not absolve the county of responsibility, and it could cost Dunn County more than the revenue the county would receive from a lease or the sale of the transfer station, Miller said.
A central location for collecting non-mandated recyclables is desirable but not convenient for people living in the four corners of the county, Miller said.
The highway department has included a proposal in the capital improvement plan for a $2 million storage building. If the transfer station can be used for storage for a while, that would result in savings for the taxpayers, he said.
No one knows if the transfer station will work for cold storage, but it’s worth it to give it a try, Miller said.
If the transfer station is not working well for cold storage in a year, then something else can be done. Keeping the transfer station will help the county work down some of the existing debt, he said.
Sixth
Dunn County is the sixth highest county in the state for long-term debt, said David Bartlett, county board supervisor from Boyceville and chair of the Dunn County Board.
The county is going to have borrow more money for long-term debt, but the capital improvement plan is intended to the keep the levy steady with planned borrowing, he said.
The highway department’s capital improvement plan for 2023 includes $135,000 to develop plans for a storage building and another $1.8 million to construct the storage building, Bartlett said.
If Dunn County can use the transfer station for cold storage for a couple of years and use the time to pay down more of the debt on the Neighbors of Dunn County, that will help with the borrowing and will go toward helping to keep the property tax levy flat, he said.
The county can try using the transfer station for cold storage for a year, and if it does not work out, then the county can always sell the transfer station, Bartlett said, adding, “but maybe it will work for a few years.”
Small space
The transfer station is a small space for county storage — it will help some but not a whole lot, said Ed Hartung, a supervisor on the Menomonie Town Board and a member of the DCSW&R board.
The transfer station has been around for 30 years, and it has depreciated out, he said.
“It’s time to cut the string and let it go,” Hartung said, noting the county should sell the transfer station “as is.”
The county will have to put money into the transfer station for cold storage, although the county should keep the 20 acres that was purchased for future use in the solid waste and recycling program, because the acreage will appreciate in value, he said.
“If that’s my piece of equipment, and it’s wore out — let’s dump it,” Hartung said.
The county should use the transfer station for the storage option for a year or two, said Tim Lienau, county board supervisor from Menomonie and a member of DCSW&R board.
“I’m not interested in selling it,” he said.
Money from the sale of the transfer station could go toward the plan for $135,000 for the highway department, said Forrest Johnson, chair of the Town of Dunn and a member of the DCSW&R Board.
“If people want to buy, it’s time to sell,” he said.
Charles Maves, county board supervisor from Boyceville and a member of the DCSW&R board, said he was not in favor of selling and that the county should “see how it plays out in a year.”
Doing the math
Zenon Smolarek, assistant director of the physical plant at UW-Stout and a member of the DCSW&R board, asked if anyone had “done the math” on the revenue from leasing the transfer station and the cost of repairs.
Could leasing the transfer station pay for the repairs in five years? he asked, adding that he was not interested in selling the transfer station.
Leasing the transfer station would be complicated because of building code compliance and liability with a lease, Gerk said.
Dunn County’s best goal is to keep the transfer station, save tax levy dollars and pay down the other debt, he said.
Earlier this year, UW-Stout had expressed an interest in using the transfer station as a Materials Recovery Facility for universities in the UW system.
Gerk said he would “love to see” a university-run “merf” at the transfer station.
In the future, if using the transfer station for cold storage does not work, maybe Menomonie and the surrounding townships could operate the transfer station as fee-based collection site for non-mandated recyclables that is open to all county residents, said Gary Bjork, county board supervisor from Colfax and chair of the DCSW&R board.
The Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling Management Board approved a motion recommending that the Dunn County Board maintain the transfer station for use as a cold storage facility for an indefinite period of time.
The vote was a voice vote, and several members of the board voted “no” on the motion.
Whether the DCSW&R board remains will be up to the Dunn County Board, Miller said.
If the county board approves retaining the transfer station, the transfer station will be transferred to the facilities committee, and there are no other pending business items for the DCSW&R board, he said.
The June 8 meeting “may be the last meeting for a while” for the DCSW&R board, Miller said.
Terry Stamm, representative for the Village of Elk Mound and a member of the DCSW&R board, suggested that a meeting for a report on the auction of surplus items from the transfer station might be worthwhile.

