DCSW&R receives four letters of interest for transfer station
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — The Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling Management Board has received four letters of interest pertaining to the transfer station on state Highway 29 west of Menomonie.
The deadline for the letters was December 31, and letters were received from Menomonie Disposal, Durand Sanitation, UW-Stout and Paul’s Industrial Garage, said Morgan Gerk, director of the Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling Division.
The letters all represent “great proposals,” and each of the entities has a vested interest in obtaining the transfer station one way or the other, either through a lease or by purchasing the property, Gerk said.
Dunn County ceased operation of the solid waste and recycling program as of December 31, and the municipalities in the county have started their own solid waste and recycling programs.
Tim Lienau, county board supervisor from Menomonie and a member of the DCSW&R board, asked if there has been a consensus of the board on whether to sell or lease the transfer station.
Gary Bjork, county board supervisor from Colfax and chair of the DCSW&R board, said in his opinion, leasing the transfer station for a few years would be more favorable.
If the transfer station is leased, that will give the municipalities time to see if they want to continue with their own programs or whether there would be interest in developing another county program, he said.
If the transfer station is sold, then there would be no options left open for a county solid waste and recycling program, Bjork said.
Earlier in the meeting, Gerk read a letter dated January 8 from Menomonie Mayor Randy Knaack about the transfer station.
Knaack said he was glad to hear Dunn County was considering leasing or selling the transfer station and that there would be a benefit to having the facility available for solid waste and recycling.
Knaack expressed the hope that one criteria for the sale or lease would be that the transfer station is open to all Dunn County residents.
The City of Menomonie and the surrounding townships are doing their best for solid waste and recycling, but if the transfer station could be open and provide for non-mandated recyclables for a fee, it would provide another disposal option for county residents, he wrote.
20 acres
Ed Hartung, a member of the DCSW&R board, asked if the 20 acres across the road from the transfer station also would be part of a lease or part of a sale.
Hartung said he believed the 20 acres should be sold because it would generate revenue for the county from the sale and would then generate property tax revenue for the county.
The 20 acres has not yet been part of the discussion, Bjork said, adding that the land is zoned for use as a disposal facility, which would bring a better price than it would for farmland.
Charles Maves, county board supervisor from Boyceville and a member of the DCSW&R board, said he, too, favored leasing the transfer station for a few years.
The 20 acres across the road is being rented for farmland now, and if the transfer station is leased, “we can see how things shake out,” Maves said.
The Dunn County Board approved purchasing 20 acres to expand the county’s solid waste and recycling center in March of 2017. The property was purchased for $8,750 per acre from Justin Merritt for a total price of $175,000.
The entire parcel where the 20 acres is located is 29 acres, which was appraised at $137,000. Dunn County originally proposed purchasing it for $5,000 per acre for a total of $145,000, but that offer, and several subsequent offers were turned down by the landowner.
A couple of DCSW&R board members also asked if the transfer station would be sold or leased “as is” or whether the facility would need repairs and improvements first.
Any lease or sale agreement will clearly state who is responsible for what. The building is 30 years old, and it is 15 years beyond its originally projected lifespan, Gerk said.
Appraisal
The next step in deciding whether the transfer station should be leased or sold is to obtain an appraisal for the property.
Gerk said he had contacted the appraiser who had appraised the Government Center on Wilson Avenue prior to the building being sold to the City of Menomonie.
That appraiser has since retired, but he recommended contacting J.C. Norby & Associates, a real estate appraisal company out of Chippewa Falls, Gerk said.
J.C. Norby & Associates has agreed to do the appraisal of the transfer station at a cost of $2,300, he said.
The 20-acre parcel by the transfer station will be appraised at the same time but it will be separate from the appraisal of the transfer station, Gerk said, adding that he planned to meet with the appraiser soon and that the appraiser has said he would be able to get to the appraisal in the first half of February.
Bjork said he had talked to Dunn County’s corporation counsel about the appraisal and about the DCSW&R board discussing selling or leasing the transfer station in closed session.
If the discussion is in closed session, board members may feel that they can discuss their opinions more freely, he said.
Keith Strey, Dunn County’s chief financial officer, said a financial analysis would have to be done, too, to determine whether leasing or selling the transfer station would be in the best financial interest of the county.
A revenue stream from a lease would have to be factored into the county’s budget, he said.
Terry Stamm, Elk Mound village trustee and a member of the DCSW&R board, asked about the acreage at the transfer station.
There are between 2.5 and three open, usable acres at the transfer station, although the entire parcel is more than three acres, Gerk said.
Timeline
Dave Bartlett, county board supervisor from Boyceville and chair of the Dunn County Board, said the appraisal would likely lead to more questions that would then need more answers.
The timeline for making a decision on whether to lease or sell the transfer station could be longer rather than shorter. The DCSW&R board could make a recommendation to the Dunn County Board in April, “but I could see it going until June,” Bartlett said.
Before soliciting for bids, all of the questions must be answered, Bjork said.
It would be premature to ask for bids for a lease if the county does not know for sure if the transfer station will be leased or sold, Bartlett said.
“I want a lot more information before I make a decision one way or another, and I’m sure everybody else on the board does too,” he said.
The DCSW&R board has a starting point with hiring an appraiser, and that “will lead us down the path,” Rasmussen said.
Repairs
Hartung asked about obtaining a cost for repairs at the transfer station.
If the facility is repaired, that will make a lease or sale more attractive, he said.
“I do not believe we are going to move forward with estimates for repairs,” Gerk said, adding that the DCSW&R division does not have any capital to make repairs, although possibly some minor repairs could be completed.
Stamm asked what would become of any money left in the DCSW&R fund.
How to allocate any remaining funds would be a decision of the Dunn County Board, Strey said.
Right now there are too many variables to know how much money will be left over. If Dunn County holds onto the transfer station, then the cost for insurance and other expenses will have to be factored in, he said.
Get the appraisal first, on an as-is basis, and then the decision can be made as to whether it makes sense to do any improvements at the transfer station, Strey said.
$330,000
How much money does DCSW&R owe Dunn County? Rasmussen asked.
The DCSW&R division borrowed money from the general fund last summer to keep the solid waste and recycling program going.
The amount is $330,000, Strey said.
The final audit for 2019 did reveal money remained in the DCSW&R general fund, and that may be the case for 2020, too, he said, noting that he could not recall off the top of his head the amount left in the DCSW&R general fund.
There is equipment at the transfer station, such as the end-loader, that could be repurposed, Bartlett said.
The highway department is going to need another end-loader, and it would not seem reasonable to purchase a new loader when there is one just sitting there at the transfer station, Bartlett said.
If the highway department receives the transfer station end-loader, then an amount will be transferred from the highway department account to the solid and waste and recycling account, Rasmussen said.
In the end, the decision about what to do with equipment also will be up to the Dunn County Board, Bartlett said.
Dunn County Solid Waste and Recycling will be receiving $147,492 from the municipalities for equipment at the collection sites purchased from the county to manage their own solid waste and recycling programs.
The nearly $150,000 for the sale of the equipment is expected to go toward the $330,000 that DCSW&R has borrowed from the county.
The Dunn County Solid Waste & Recycling Management Board agreed to not have a meeting in February to allow time for the appraisal to be completed and scheduled the next meeting for March 2.

