Dunn County County Deer Advisory Council turns down Holiday Hunt and antler-less hunt
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — The Dunn County Deer Advisory Council has made recommendations on a deer hunting quota and bonus tags and has agreed there should be no Holiday Hunt and no antler-less-only hunt this year.
The Dunn County C-DAC was originally scheduled to meet April 7 at the Dunn County Fish & Game Association on Pine Avenue in Menomonie but changed the meeting to a conference call format because of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Since the meeting was held by conference call, the Dunn County C-DAC was unable to take public comments, but the public is invited to submit comments online about the Dunn County C-DAC’s preliminary recommendations at the Department of Natural Resources Deer Advisory Council website during the comment period the last two weeks of April.
Last year, 6,586 deer were killed in Dunn County, said Missy Sparrow-Lien, a wildlife biologist with the DNR.
Out of the total number of deer killed, 807 were taken on public land, and 5,719 were taken on private land, she said.
One deer in Dunn County tested positive for Chronic Wasting Disease out of 430 deer heads that were tested, Sparrow-Lien said.
Quota
Al Marotz, chair of the Dunn County C-DAC, said he would like to see the quota for the deer hunt remain the same as last year at 6,400.
Using the same quota would maintain the deer herd, he said.
Over the years, the deer herd in Dunn County has tended to “slowly creep up every year,” Marotz said.
Next year, the Dunn County C-DAC should have a goal of reducing the deer herd, he said.
Reducing the deer herd is not such as easy task, though, because hunters will only put so many deer in the freezer, and then they quit hunting, Marotz said.
Setting the quota at 6,400 will make it look like an effort at trying to keep the herd size under control, Sparrow-Lien said.
Bonus tags
Setting the bonus tags at two for each deer hunting license, with 2,500 for-purchase bonus tags for private land and 250 for-purchase bonus tags for public land are good numbers, Sparrow-Lien said.
Increasing the number of for-purchase bonus tags that are available does not mean more deer will be taken during the season, Marotz noted.
Out of the bonus tags available for purchase in Dunn County in 2019, there were 250 available for public land, and 249 of those tags were purchased. Out of 2,500 tags available for purchase for private land, 972 tags were purchased and 204 were used, Sparrow-Lien said.
The success rate on the $12 purchased bonus tags was between 15 and 20 percent, with 21 percent success for the private land bonus tags and 10.8 percent success with the public land bonus tags, she said.
The Dunn County Deer Advisory Council unanimously approved a motion for a preliminary recommendation to establish the quota for this year at 6,400 deer, with two bonus tags per deer hunting license, and making 2,500 for-purchase bonus tags available for private land and 250 for-purchase bonus tags available for public land.
In addition to Marotz, members of the Dunn County Deer Advisory Council include Mike Gullickson, Paul Sterk, Dan Loonstra, Jim Thompson, Mike Benzel and Bob Bernier.
Holiday Hunt
The Dunn County Deer Advisory Council also unanimously approved a motion not to have an antler-less-only Holiday Hunt this year.
The Holiday Hunt is from December 24 to January 1.
After talking to a number of farmers and private land owners, they do not want the Holiday Hunt, Bernier said.
The farmers and other landowners believe the Holiday Hunt encourages poaching at night, he said.
The Holiday Hunt is not popular with hunters. There are not many deer shot, and the hunt makes people upset, Sterk said.
By the time December comes, deer hunters have been “chasing” deer since September, and the deer need to rest because no one knows what the winter will be like and how hard it will be for the deer herd to get through the winter, Marotz said.
Most hunters also do not like to hunt in the cold, he noted.
Since the members of the Dunn County C-DAC did not approve the Holiday Hunt, they did not need to vote on whether to extend the bow season to the end of January.
Sparrow-Lien noted that Buffalo County and Pierce County had approved two bonus tags per license, a Holiday Hunt and the extended season.
St. Croix County approved an antler-less-only season, she said.
Antler-less
With virtually no discussion, the Dunn County Deer Advisory Council unanimously approved a motion not to have an antler-less-only hunt.
Citations
In response to a question, Jaime McDermid, a conservation warden with the DNR, said while there are some citations issued for hunting without a license during deer season, there are more registration issues and more problems of hunting over bait.
Deer hunters in Wisconsin now no longer have to wear back tags, and they can register their deer over the Internet and do not have to take them to registration stations.
McDermid said most of the citations he writes come from complaints about someone hunting on private land.
DNR wardens do not go on private land unless they have received a complaint, he said.
No in-person registration and no back tags make it too easy for hunters to become poachers, Marotz said.
The DNR must change it back to in-person registration and requiring hunters to wear back tags, he said, noting that in-person registration also is part of the social and historical aspect of deer hunting in Wisconsin.
DNR personnel on the conference call said the best way to get the regulations changed back to in-person registration and deer hunters being required to wear back tags would be to contact state legislators.
Comments
Public comments about the Dunn County Deer Advisory Council’s preliminary recommendations will be accepted by the DNR from April 16 to April 28.
Public comments can be submitted through the DNR’s Deer Advisory Council website at www.dnr.wi.gov/topic/hunt/cdac.html
You can also find the website by doing a search online for “Wisconsin” “DNR” and “cdac.”
The Dunn County C-DAC’s preliminary recommendations will be finalized at a meeting scheduled for May 5 at Dunn County Fish & Game.
Meeting information is available on the C-DAC website, and if the May 5 meeting also ends up being held as a conference call, the telephone number and the access code can be found on the website.
The Dunn County Deer Advisory Council’s preliminary recommendations also will be posted on the C-DAC website.
The recommendations will be taken under consideration by the Wisconsin Natural Resources Board June 23 and June 24.

