Judge extends probation 2 years for Boyceville woman who embezzled $48,000 from Bremer Bank in Elk Mound
By LeAnn R. Ralph
MENOMONIE — A Dunn County judge has extended the probation for a Boyceville woman found guilty of stealing $48,000 from Bremer Bank in Elk Mound and who has paid $5,500 of the restitution after three years of probation.
Amber C. Goodell appeared in Dunn County Circuit Court before Judge Rod Smeltzer April 27.
Goodell did not have an attorney present in court to represent her.
Goodell started working for Bremer Bank in December of 2003. The money Goodell took from the bank disappeared between January of 2010 and August of 2013.
Judge William Stewart Jr., at a court hearing in May of 2014, accepted Goodell’s plea of no contest, found her guilty, and sentenced Goodell to three years of probation and 15 days in jail and also ordered her to complete 120 hours of community service and to pay restitution of $48,000.
Judge Stewart has since retired from the bench.
Goodell’s attorney during the 2014 hearing, William Laman, told the court Goodell was ready to pay $5,000 in restitution the day of plea hearing.
Goodell has expressed remorse for stealing the money, has many letters of recommendation, has the support of her family, wrote a letter of apology to Bremer Bank in October and has been cooperative with the investigation, Laman said at the 2014 court hearing.
At the April 27 hearing, Judge Smeltzer noted that a termination of probation hearing would be in order if Goodell had been farther along in paying the restitution.
Judge Smeltzer wondered how much Goodell had been paying per month on the $48,000 in restitution.
Goodell said she had been paying $20 or $40 per month because she’d had other bills to pay but that now she would be making larger payments.
Judge Smeltzer said that $5,500 was “not a good faith effort,” and ordered that probation be extended for two years “for a stronger effort” at paying the restitution.
Judge Smeltzer suggested that $500 a month in payments would be appropriate.
According to the criminal complaint, two representatives from Bremer Bank had been conducting an internal investigation when they discovered that $48,000 had been embezzled by an employee at Bremer Bank’s location in Elk Mound.
When deputies asked Goodell to explain what had happened, Goodell said she had started stealing money from the bank several years earlier, perhaps in 2010, and that she had started with smaller amounts and then had progressed to larger amounts until a total of $48,000 had been stolen.
Goodell told investigators she had removed the money from her cash drawer at the bank and had concealed the missing money by making false transactions with the bank’s vault.
Goodell also told investigators that she “pretty much knew she was caught” about a month earlier when she had created a fake transaction indicating the missing money had been sold to the Federal Reserve.
According to a fact sheet provided by Bremer Bank, on August 30, a scheduled audit of all the teller drawers and the vault, in preparation for converting to a new teller system, revealed that all teller drawers and the bank vault balanced.
The criminal complaint goes on to say that on October 2, one of the tellers at Bremer Bank in Elk Mound received a telephone call from the bank’s accounting department regarding an entry made on August 30 in the amount of $48,000 for a “sell” of cash to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.

