Skip to content

Novotney sentenced to 25 years prison and 18 years probation for assaulting teenage boys

By LeAnn R. Ralph

MENOMONIE —  A 46-year-old Boyceville man found guilty on three of 13 counts related to the sexual assault of teenage boys has been sentenced to 25 years in prison and 18 years of probation.

Christopher J. Novotney appeared in Dunn County Circuit Court November 2 with his attorney, Matthew Krische, for a sentencing hearing before Judge James Peterson.

Judge Peterson accepted Novotney’s plea of no contest at a July court hearing and found him guilty on two felony counts of the repeated sexual assault of the same child and one felony count of exposing a child to harmful material.

Judge Peterson dismissed the remaining charges but ordered them entered into the record for sentencing.

Novotney was charged in connection with incidents that had happened at his home on county Highway K in the Town of Stanton regarding sexual contact with a number of teenaged boys.

Although none of the victims or their family members wanted to make statements during the November 2 sentencing hearing, Marcia Finder of the Dunn County District Attorney’s office and Assistant District Attorney Holly Wood-Webster read statements from the parents of two of the victims.

Judge Peterson said the court had received a number of letters from the victims and their parents.

Both of the letters read in court indicated the parents had trusted Novotney with their sons when the boys had gone to Novotney’s house or when Novotney had taken them hunting, fishing or to sporting events.

“You were a family friend. Now you are a pedophile,” said one letter.

Both letter writers indicated they had noticed changes in their sons’ behavior and in their personalities as a result of Novotney’s sexual abuse.

“Please find justice for our son,” said the first letter.

The second letter writer said she had seen a change in her son over the past few years and that eventually her son had asked his parents to lie about him being able to go to Novotney’s house.

The son would go to Novotney’s house sometimes, but he would not stay overnight, “and now I know why,” the letter stated.

The letter went on to say that whenever they saw Novotney at school events, he was always cordial, friendly and behaved the same way toward them that he always had, but in reality “you were a child predator.”

The letter writer now wonders if Novotney had only attended school events to look for more victims.

“We would give anything to have our son back,” the letter said, adding that no prison sentence would be long enough to make up for the damage Novotney had done to his victims.

“You are the lowest type of criminal,” the letter concluded.

Wood-Webster

The abuse in Boyceville “came to light” February 23 when “one brave 17-year-old” asked other boys if they had been touched inappropriately, Wood-Webster said.

Wood-Webster is the prosecutor in the Novotney case.

Novotney had been well-respected in the community and had volunteered at a variety of school and church events, she noted.

The defendant worked to control his version of the events, and after he had talked to investigators, he told law enforcement officials they did not need to talk to the boys again, Wood-Webster said.

Novotney showed the victims pornographic videos and gave them alcohol and initiated sexual contact with the boys while they were sleeping, she said.

In an interview in February, Novotney admitted to some sexual contact with the boys, but now the defendant denies touching the boys under their clothing and said that four of the incidents were accidental, Wood-Webster said.

The abused teenagers, some of whom were 14 when Novotney started sexually assaulting them, could suffer a variety of problems as a result of the abuse, including shame, guilt, depression, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, and self harm through drug or alcohol abuse, she said.

Some people have said the boys should have known better, “but that is blaming the victim,” Wood-Webster said.

One family member asked for a sentence of 16 years in prison for each victim, which would amount to a total of 96 years in prison, she said.

The pre-sentence investigation recommends five or six years of incarceration on each of the two counts of the repeated second-degree sexual assault of a child and 24 to 36 months of probation for exposing a child to harmful material.

“That is ridiculously low,” Wood-Webster said, adding that what the parents had asked for was more appropriate.

Wood-Webster asked the court to sentence Novotney to 20 years in prison on each of the counts of second-degree sexual assault, to be served consecutively, along with ten to 15 years of extended supervision as well as lifetime registry as a sex offender.

A longer prison sentence will give the victims time to heal and move on with their lives without having to worry they will run into Novotney somewhere, she said.

Wood-Webster said the parents of the victims also were asking for restitution to cover the cost of counseling for their sons.

If the victims had been 13 or younger, Novotney would have faced more serious charges, Class B felonies instead of Class C felonies, she said.

Krische

Krische, Novotney’s attorney, said he believed the sentencing recommendation in the PSI was appropriate.

Sentencing Novotney to 40 years in prison would not protect the public, he said.

Satisfying a need for retribution is understandable, but the way to protect society is not through a long prison term, but rather by Novotney getting the treatment he needs, Krische said.

Novotney is 46 years old and has no prior convictions on sex offenses and no history of possessing pornography or of inappropriate behavior, he said.

“Something” had to have happened to make Novotney engage in this kind of behavior. A man in his 40s just does not suddenly begin to sexually abuse teenaged boys, Krische said.

While talking to Novotney, Krische said he had learned that the defendant had been abused by the boyfriend of his friend’s mother when he was 11 years old.

Novotney needs sex offender treatment so he understands what happened and why, he said.

The defendant understands he needs treatment and incarceration, which “shows an insight,” Krische said.

Since 1992, Novotney has had six jobs, he said.

A need exists to protect the public, and incarceration is appropriate, but not for 41.5 years. If Novotney is sentenced to 40 years in prison, he will be released in his 80s, and that will be “a life sentence,” Krische said.

A more appropriate sentence would be five or six years, or even as many as eight years in prison, along with ten years of extended supervision, served concurrently on the two counts of repeated sexual assault, along with 24 to 36 months of probation on the count of exposing a child to harmful material, he said.

Novotney

Novotney took the opportunity to address the court, and as soon as he started speaking, he began to weep.

Novotney said he “thinks about it everyday” and wishes he could do more than apologize to all of the victims.

“I am truly sorry for causing sadness and heartache … I would change the past if I could,” he said.

Novotney said he understands that he must take responsibility for his actions and went on to apologize to his wife.

“I will always love you,” he said.

Novotney also apologized to his children and said he wanted to be part of their lives if they wanted to have him be part of their lives.

Whatever the court decides, the sentence “will continue the rest of my life,” Novotney said, adding that he takes responsibility for his actions and asked for forgiveness from his victims although he said he also knows his victims are unlikely to forgive him.

Judge Peterson

The maximum sentence for the Class C felonies of the repeated second-degree sexual assault of a child is 40 years in prison and/or  a $100,000 fine on each count, Judge Peterson said.

The maximum sentence for the Class I felony of exposing a child to harmful material is 3.5 years, with the total among the three felonies being 83 years and six months, he said.

If the boys had been younger than 13, the maximum penalty would have been much stiffer, with a  mandatory 25 years in prison on each count, Judge Peterson said.

At the time of the abuse, Novotney was 45, and the victims were 15, “and the thought of the boys ‘coming on’ to you is pretty ridiculous,” he said.

At one point in the investigation, Novotney had indicated the teenagers had been willing participants and had initiated sexual contact with him.

Novotney’s crimes are of the kind that will “keep on victimizing.” Some of the victims will deal with the abuse better than others, Judge Peterson said.

Suicide is not unheard of among victims of sexual abuse, and sometimes they become perpetrators themselves, he said.

Novotney often minimized his actions, did not take full responsibility, and said 90 percent of what the boys had said was not true, Judge Peterson said.

The abuse happened on numerous occasions with multiple victims who were at a vulnerable age, he said.

Novotney used volunteerism to “groom” kids and to have access to them, Judge Peterson said.

“It seems odd that the monster came out when you were in your mid 40s,” he said.

Sentence

Judge Peterson sentenced Novotney to 12 years and six months in prison on each of the two counts of the repeated second-degree sexual assault of a child for a total of 25 years in prison along with extended supervision of seven years and six months on each count for a total of 15 years.

The prison terms and extended supervision for each count will be served consecutively.

Judge Peterson withheld sentence on the charge of exposing a child to harmful material and placed Novotney on 36 months of probation to be served consecutively to the extended supervision on the other two felony counts.

All together, between prison and extended supervision, Novotney will be under supervision for 43 years, at which time, he will be 89 years old.

By the time Novotney is 89, the risk to the community will be much less, if Novotney survives that long, Judge Peterson said.

Conditions set by Judge Peterson for the extended supervision and the probation include ordering  Novotney to complete all programming that is required by his probation agent.

In addition, Novotney is not allowed to have unsupervised contact with anyone under the age of 18.

Judge Peterson also ordered lifetime registry for Novotney as a serious sex offender.

Wood-Webster had asked the court to order Novotney not to live in Boyceville when he is released on extended supervision, but Judge Peterson said the law does not allow him to make such an order.

Returning to Boyceville would be “poor judgement on your part … but that would be 24 years from now,” Judge Peterson said.

Novotney also was ordered to provide a DNA sample and to pay court costs and the DNA surcharge of $250 for each count.

Any money that Novotney earns in prison must go toward restitution to pay the cost of counseling for the victims, Judge Peterson said.

Novotney is now divorced and “is probably penniless,” the judge noted, adding that although Novotney will not earn much in prison, the money must still be paid toward restitution.

As a convicted felon, Novotney will not be allowed to vote in any election for the next 43 years. He also is not allowed to own firearms or body armor and is not allowed to possess or purchase alcohol or controlled substances and will not be allowed to enter bars, taverns or liquor stores while on extended supervision.

Novotney was given credit for 254 days already served in the Dunn County jail.

He has remained in custody on a $50,000 cash bail set February 25.